is one of the best praise that created by gilbert ryan gilbert ryan says in searching for the soul one cannot simultaneously be the hunter and the hunted gilbert trial was a philosopher and was a former professor gilbert ryan produced a critic on the court's idea that the mind is distinct from the body gerbil wrote the concept of mine were rejected the notion that mental states are separable from physical states gilbert reil called the distinction between mind and matter a category mistake because of its attempt to analyze the relationship or the relation between the mind and the body as if the two were terms of the same categories this was the footnote or so to say it was mentioned by not 2013. if you're going to put into the reality actually is not really against renegade hearts you're just just trying points against the card's theory are the relation between mind and body are isolated process or processes mental processes are intelligent acts and are not distinct from each other the creation of the mind is itself an intelligent app the rationalists view that mental acts are distinct from physical acts and that there is a mental world distinct from the physical world is a misconception gilbert reil described this distinction between mind and body as the dogma of the ghost in the machine where he explained there is no hidden entity called or ghosts called soul inside the machine called body gilbert trial criticized the theory that the mind is a place where mental images are apprehend perceived or remembered and feelings do not belong to a mental world separate from physical world sensations to your feelings and only god can read our mind and our heart but not the human knowledge memory imagination and any other abilities of dispositions do not reside within the mind as if the mind were a separate or a space rather in which this could be stored or located if gilbert trial believed that the concept of a distinct self is not real where do we get our sense of soul gilbert ryan asserted that it is from our has something to do with our inner conviction as human as we are i mean speaks louder than words for example you think yourself as a kind of person because you ask of kindness your actions define your own concept observe really you are again this is bye for now