Bleeding Kansas and Bleeding Sumner

Jul 30, 2024

Bleeding Kansas and Bleeding Sumner Lecture Notes

Overview

  • Focus: Events and cultural institutions showing the U.S. division in the 1850s
  • Also covered: Political party platforms in 1856, 1860 election parties/candidates and their platforms

Bleeding Kansas

  • Context: Kansas territory conflict between Free Soilers (anti-slavery) and pro-slavery settlers
    • Kansas and Nebraska were under popular sovereignty (vote to decide slave/free status)
  • **Key Events: **
    • First Territorial Election:
      • Border ruffians (Missouri residents) crossed into Kansas to vote illegally
      • Resulted in pro-slavery legislature legalizing slavery and criminalizing anti-slavery actions
    • Federal Response:
      • U.S. under Buchanan recognized the pro-slavery government despite knowing about voter fraud
    • Free Soilers' Response:
      • Established a rival government and anti-slavery constitution
      • Small-scale civil war erupted, named 'Bleeding Kansas' by the national press
    • The Sack of Lawrence (May 1856):
      • Pro-slavery forces attacked, causing property damage
    • John Brown & Pottawatomie Massacre (1856):
      • John Brown (abolitionist leader) attacked and killed 5 pro-slavery men
      • Led to further outrage and violence, reinforcing the notion of a pre-Civil War civil war

Bleeding Sumner

  • Event: - Massachusetts Senator Charles Sumner gave an anti-slavery speech in Senate
    • Criticized Senator Andrew Butler and advocated recognizing the free government in Kansas
  • Retaliation:
    • Preston Brooks, Butler's nephew, attacked Sumner with a cane
    • Sumner nearly beaten to death, suffered permanent brain damage
    • Brooks received support from the South, including replacement canes
    • Sumner reelected by Massachusetts as a symbol of defiance

Summary

  • The events of Bleeding Kansas and Bleeding Sumner illustrate the intense sectional conflict leading up to the Civil War.
  • Both instances showed the lengths to which pro-slavery and anti-slavery forces would go, including violence and political manipulation.