Lateral Torsional Buckling in Beams

Jul 12, 2024

Lateral Torsional Buckling in Beams

Introduction

  • Deflection: Beams deflect in the loading direction.
  • Lateral Deflection: Begins with increased load, not intuitive.
  • Lateral Torsional Buckling (LTB): Sideways deflection and twisting, can be destructive.
  • Historical Context: Caused the Station Square Collapse (1988).

Why LTB Occurs

  • Compression and Tension: Top flange compressed, bottom flange stretched.
  • Buckling: Compressed members deflect laterally.
  • Beam Buckling: Top half in compression wants to buckle, bottom half in tension wants to straighten out. This opposite movement causes twisting and lateral deflection.

Resistance to Torsional Buckling

  • Strong Sections: Beams strong in torsion, like closed sections (pipes, square tubes), resist LTB.
  • Weak Sections: Wide flange sections (W-sections) and beams weak in bending about the y-axis are prone to LTB.

Types of Deformations

  1. Vertical Deflection: Due to load application.
  2. Lateral Deflection: Sideways movement.
  3. Twisting: Rotational deformation.
  • Each deformation induces stresses, making LTB destructive.

Load Propagation and Stiffness

  • Load Redistribution: Initially applied load gets redistributed to axes with lower stiffness, causing large deformations under small loads.
  • Susceptible Beams: Weak in torsion and y-axis bending, e.g., deep W-sections or slender rectangular beams.
  • Stocky Beams: Premature yielding and bi-axial bending due to cross-bending.

Illustrative Comparison

  • Scenarios Analyzed in Abaqus for an 8-meter beam:

    1. Point load at mid-span at section centroid.
    2. Point load at mid-span on top flange.
    3. Point load at mid-span with lateral bracings.

  • Results: Braced beam performed best, achieving full bending capacity.

Experiment on Open vs. Closed Sections

  • Box Section: Comparable deflections to load direction, yielding and local buckling, no lateral deflection. Collapsed at ~72 kg.
  • I-Section: Lateral deflection noticeable at ~36 kg, failed at 45 kg. Box beam had a 60% higher capacity.

Dealing with Lateral Torsional Buckling

  • Lateral Bracing: Most common solution, braces compression flange to prevent lateral deflection.
  • Section Selection: In cases where bracing isn’t possible, select sections resistant to LTB.

Cause of Instability

  • Imperfections: Slight initial bends amplified under load, causing instability.
  • Load Application: Load at top flange increases bending and torsional load, accelerating buckling.

Design Codes and Equations

  • Challenges: Difficulty in capturing LTB effects with one equation.
  • Modifications: Design codes use modification factors for different bending moment distributions.
  • Considerations: Include stress concentrations, end connections, bending moment diagrams, slenderness, and load types.

Critical Thinking in Engineering

  • Evaluation: Engineers assess multiple failure scenarios to design safe structures.
  • Support: Platforms like Brilliant offer interactive courses to develop critical thinking.

Conclusion

  • This concludes the explanation of LTB, emphasizing understanding and preventive measures.
  • Call to Action: Engage with the content, provide feedback, and consider subscribing.