China Rejects Sweet Baby Inc Offer

Jul 23, 2024

Notes on China Rejecting Sweet Baby Inc Offer

Key Points

  • China has rejected a $7 million offer from Sweet Baby Inc to influence their game development negatively.
  • The studio Game Science, developing Black Myth: Wukong, opted to proceed on their own without consultancy.
  • This rejection generated significant backlash on social media platforms like Weibo.

Context of the Situation

  • Sweet Baby Inc has a history of pressuring developers to pay for consultancy to avoid negative press.
  • Developers often fear backlash from journalists perceived as supportive of Sweet Baby Inc’s ideology, which can result in accusations based on various biases (e.g., racism, sexism).
  • This scenario reflects broader trends across the gaming industry, particularly in America.

Allegations and Responses

  • Articles against Black Myth: Wukong criticized the game even prior to its release, accusing it of not aligning with Western progressive values.
  • Developers are often coerced into seeking consultancy to mitigate negative coverage.
  • Insiders from Game Science indicated that they faced threats of bad press regarding their understanding of American socio-political dynamics.

The Role of Journalists and Consultancy Firms

  • A concerning pattern exists where former journalists work with consultancy firms, creating a cycle of pressure on game developers.
  • Sweet Baby Inc is accused of acting in concert with journalists to manipulate narratives surrounding game titles to benefit consultancy.
  • Player backlash can be weaponized to persuade developers into consulting relationships, forcing changes in their creative processes.

Game Science's Stance

  • The studio’s director expressed a strong disdain for pandering to consultancy firms, prioritizing the preferences of their intended player base.
  • Statements made by the director included a rejection of sensitive, progressive themes in storytelling, focusing instead on authenticity to their audience.
    • “F the sissies,” comments indicate a refusal to cater to perceived trends in favor of creating meaningful content for their core audience.

Broader Implications

  • The incident highlights a shift in game development dynamics, indicating Chinese developers may pursue creative independence absent of Western constraints.
  • An emerging sentiment surfaces that suggests gamers are turning to Eastern developers for authentic gaming experiences, potentially leaving Western developers behind.
  • The gaming industry may see a long-term trend of increasing dissatisfaction with Western development norms and a movement towards Eastern developers.

Discussion Points

  • The ongoing influence of consultancy firms and their relationship with journalism warrants examination, particularly regarding their effects on game quality and developer autonomy.
  • A question arises: Are negative perceptions of new titles like Black Myth: Wukong genuinely warranted, or are they a product of external influences?
  • Engagement with this topic is encouraged to gauge opinions on whether Sweet Baby Inc embodies problematic practices in gaming narratives.