James Charles Palette Comparison Overview

Aug 31, 2024

James Charles YouTube Presentation Notes

Introduction

  • James Charles welcomes viewers to his YouTube channel.
  • Reflects on past experiences with dupes of his products.
  • Mentions the iconic collaboration with Morphe and the subsequent knockoff of that palette.

Background on the New Product

  • His brand "Painted" launched the "Basic Canvas" eyeshadow palette earlier this year.
  • A knockoff of the "Basic Canvas" palette has appeared on Shein.
  • Plans to compare the original palette with the Shein dupe in this video.

Overview of the Basic Canvas Palette

  • The Basic Canvas palette has gained popularity, especially on TikTok.
  • Emphasis on the hard work and detail put into the palette’s design and packaging:
    • Took 2 years to develop.
    • Features a unique raised canvas design.
    • Packaging designed to look like an artist's work.

Comparison of Packaging

  • Original Palette:
    • High-quality, detailed packaging with the name "Basic Canvas" debossed.
  • Shein Dupe:
    • Poorly made packaging with incorrect branding (e.g., "Ken Miler").
    • Lacks the quality and design detail of the original.

Comparison of Palettes

  • Weight:
    • Original palette is heavy and feels high-quality.
    • The dupe is lightweight and feels cheap.
  • Color Stories:
    • Both palettes contain neutral shades, but the dupe lacks creativity and originality.
    • Names of shades often mimic those in the original palette but are poorly thought out.

Pricing

  • Basic Canvas Palette:
    • Priced at $55 for 24 shades.
  • Shein Dupe:
    • Priced at $13, making it more affordable but questionable in quality.

Sponge Comparison

  • The Shein sponge closely resembles his "Painted Sponge" but lacks quality.
  • Original sponge is softer and doubles in size when wet, while the dupe is more dense and absorbs product poorly.

Makeup Application Session

  • James applies makeup using both palettes.
  • Eyeshadow Application:
    • Original palette performs much better with vibrant colors and good pigmentation.
    • The dupe produces patchy and uneven results.
  • Final Look:
    • Clear difference between the two sides; original looks vibrant and well-blended, while the dupe looks flat and lacks pigment.

Conclusion

  • While the dupe is not the worst he has tried, it cannot compete with the original.
  • Emphasizes the quality, uniqueness, and effort behind his brand, "Painted."
  • Thanks viewers for their support and encourages them to like and subscribe.