Analysis of Justice in "And Then There Were None"

May 2, 2024

Summary:

In this lecture, we discussed Agatha Christie's novel "And Then There Were None," wherein ten individuals are lured to an isolated island under false pretenses and systematically murdered according to a nursery rhyme. The murderer is revealed at the end to be the seemingly impartial judge, Justice Wargrave, who ingeniously stages his own death to remain unsuspected.

Key Points:

  • Plot Overview: Ten people are brought to Soldier Island by a mysterious host. Each character has a dark past involving actions that led to the deaths of other individuals, which law enforcement cannot address. They are killed one by one, following the lines of a nursery rhyme.

  • Characters: Key characters include Justice Wargrave, Vera Claythorne (a former governess), Philip Lombard (an adventurer), Dr. Armstrong (a former surgeon), and William Bloor (a detective).

  • Themes:

    • Justice vs. Vigilantism: Wargrave takes upon himself to deliver justice where the legal system has failed.
    • Concealed Identities and Deception: The guests hide their pasts and true selves, contributing to the atmosphere of suspicion and dread.
    • Fear and Survival: Characters react differently to the unfolding horrors, showcasing various responses to fear and the instinct for survival.
  • Structure and Narration: The story employs a third-person omniscient point of view, allowing insights into the thoughts and fears of characters as their numbers dwindle.

  • Symbolism:

    • The Island: Represents isolation and the inescapable nature of one's past actions.
    • Nursery Rhyme: Symbolizes inevitability and foretells the fate of the characters.
  • Justice Wargrave's Motivation: Wargrave, claiming to be a just man, believes in punishing those who have caused deaths that they have not been held accountable for legally. His elaborate plan to kill each guest, including himself, is driven by his self-righteous belief in serving justice.

  • Conclusion:

    • The novel concludes with the revelation that Wargrave, having faked his own death, was the mastermind behind the murders. He plans his suicide in a way that continues to affirm his control over the situation, leaving behind a confession detailing his motivations and planning, to be discovered if his bottle is ever found.