Assessing if certain cars pronounced 'Dead on Arrival' deserve better recognition.
996 Porsche 911
Production: 1997-2006.
Notable Aspects: First 911 with water-cooled engine; replaced air-cooled engines.
Criticism: Hardcore enthusiasts & journalists disliked the transition to water-cooled engines and the unique headlight design. Interior also criticized for being too simple.
Public Reception: Despite criticism, sold well due to its performance (189 mph top speed).
Summary: Largely considered “fake news” by presenters—car's performance and design appreciated by users.
F10 BMW M5
Production: 2011-2016.
Notable Aspects: First M5 with a twin-turbo V8 engine; 7-speed dual-clutch or 6-speed manual transmission.
Criticism: Compared unfavorably to past models, particularly the E60's V10 engine; accused of artificial sound enhancement.
Public Reception: Positive reactions on its overall design and performance. Manual transmission availability praised in the U.S.
Summary: Criticisms seen as exaggerated—performance and design well-received.
Mark V Toyota Supra
Debut: Mark V generation.
Notable Aspects: Collaboration with BMW; came after a long hiatus of the Supra line.
Criticism: Labeled as a rebadged BMW Z4; initial lack of manual transmission criticized.
Public Reception: Positive reception over time—praised for its design and performance. Later included manual transmission.