Lecture: Comparing Kant and Aristotle's Ethical Philosophies

Introduction

• The lecture aims to explore and compare the ethical philosophies of Immanuel Kant and Aristotle.
• Understanding these philosophies provides insight into different approaches to ethics and moral decision-making.

Aristotle's Ethical Philosophy

Virtue Ethics

• Central Concept: Virtue
  • Emphasis on character and virtues.
  • Good life achieved by developing good character traits (virtues).
• Eudaimonia
  • Aristotle's idea of happiness or flourishing.
  • Achieved through the practice of virtues and living in accordance with reason.
• Habituation
  • Virtues are developed through practice and repetition.

Role of Reason

• Rationality is key in developing virtues.
• Practical wisdom (phronesis) guides ethical behavior.

Kant's Ethical Philosophy

Deontological Ethics

• Central Concept: Duty
  • Moral actions are those performed out of duty.
  • The rightness of an action based on adherence to rules or duties.

Categorical Imperative

• A foundational concept in Kant's ethics.
• Formulations:
  • Act only according to that maxim whereby you can, at the same time, will that it should become a universal law.
  • Treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, always as an end and never as a means only.

Autonomy and Reason

• Emphasis on autonomy and rationality in moral decision-making.
• Morality is grounded in rational will, independent of external influences.

Key Differences

• Focus: Aristotle's focus on character and virtue vs. Kant's focus on duty and rules.
• Moral Motivation: Aristotle on acting according to virtues developed through habituation; Kant on acting from duty.
• Reason's Role: Both emphasize reason, but Aristotle sees it as guiding virtue, while Kant sees it as the force of duty.

Conclusion

• Both philosophies offer valuable insights into ethics, with differing methods of evaluating moral actions.
• Understanding both approaches enriches comprehension of ethical theories and their applications in everyday life.

---

These notes provide a structured overview of Kant and Aristotle's ethical philosophies, highlighting their core concepts and differences.