🌍

6f. Darwinism vs Social Darwinism (US History part 2)

Mar 4, 2025

Lecture Notes: Darwin's Theory of Evolution vs. Social Darwinism

Key Concepts

Natural Selection

  • Variation & Heredity: Variation in populations is heritable and can affect survival and reproduction.
  • Evolution Over Generations: Traits that enhance survival can become more common over generations.
  • Misconception: No race or organism is "more evolved"; all have been evolving.

Social Darwinism

  • Misapplication of Darwin's Theories: Sociologists, like Herbert Spencer, applied Darwin's ideas to justify social hierarchies and inequalities.
  • Survival of the Fittest: Coined by Spencer, not Darwin, to explain social disparities.
  • Justification for Inaction: Used to justify social inequalities and lack of government intervention.

Social & Biological Misinterpretations

Eugenics

  • Misguided Beliefs: Idea of improving human race by breeding out undesirables.
  • Biological Reality: Reducing genetic variation is detrimental to population health.
  • Uncertainty in Evolutionary Adaptation: Variation prepares populations for unforeseen challenges (e.g., diseases).

Cultural vs. Biological Confusion

  • Cultural Superiority: Mistaken for biological superiority; cultural traits labeled as biological inferiority.
  • Colonialism & Civilization: Justified by the idea of "civilizing" less evolved cultures.

Biological Misunderstandings

Lamarckian Evolution

  • Herbert Spencer's Error: Believed in acquired traits being genetically passed on, which is incorrect.
  • Genetic Traits: Acquired traits aren't inherited genetically; teaching does not alter genetics.

Biological Basis of Race

  • Race as a Social Construct: More genetic variation within races than between them.
  • Genetic Similarity: Humans are 99.9% genetically identical.
  • Arbitrary Categorization: Race is a superficial categorization with little genetic basis.