🔧

Understanding Criteria and Constraints in Design

Sep 3, 2024

Engineering Design Process Lecture Notes

Introduction

  • Previously covered: Design statement and defining the problem.
  • Focus of this lecture: Defining criteria and constraints.

Criteria and Constraints

Criteria

  • Definition: What you want your design to achieve or its purpose.
  • Importance: Essential to understand for the successful building of the product.
  • Examples: For a pet carrier:
    • Safely transport the pet.
    • Provide food and water if needed.
    • Ensure adequate air for animals like turtles, not fish.

Constraints

  • Definition: Rules or limitations restricting what you can do.
  • Examples:
    • Materials: Availability of materials like cardboard, wood, metal.
    • Time: Limited time to complete the project (e.g., arrive at the vet before closing).
    • Cost: Budget limitations (e.g., not using expensive materials like gold).

Importance of Defining Criteria and Constraints

  • Helps in focusing on design and keeping ideas realistic.
  • More precise definition leads to a better-focused design process.

Practical Application Example

  • Pet Carrier Problem:
    • Design and construct a carrier to safely transport a pet to the vet.
    • Considerations for criteria and constraints:
      • Safe transport, air supply, material choice, time, and cost.

Transition to Next Step

  • Next stage: Brainstorming Process.
  • Use criteria and constraints to guide brainstorming:
    • Consider problem, research, desired design outcomes, and limitations as a foundation for idea generation.