Transcript for:
Comprehensive Review of Soundcore Sleep A20

The Soundcore Sleep A20 have ticked a key  box that's rarely ticked when I review sleep   headphones. All too often, when I test headphones  in bed, I end up removing them after an hour or   two because they're uncomfortable. But I've had  no problem wearing the A20s all night long on the   many nights I've used them in the last month. Before I dive into the review, I think it's   important to clarify one of the main reasons  they're so comfortable, and that's because   their very small size is largely possible because  they don't have active noise cancellation. The   good news is that they make up for the lack of ANC  with a ton of white noise and ambient and nature   sounds on the app, which you can use to mask  noise. You can also play your own audio if you   prefer. Later in the video, I'll be talking about  some tests I did to see how well they block out   snoring and music, as well as how they compared  to some other headphones. But before I do,   let's take a closer look at the earbuds. They arrived in a small and smart-looking   box. The earbuds are housed in a round-shaped  case, which has a beige color and a smooth   feel. It takes a while to get used to opening the  case as the top slides open rather than flips,   and the arrow symbol is very small. The earbuds  are remarkably small with interchangeable wings   and tips so you can get a good fit. The tips  have a double layer to improve noise isolation,   though they aren't as effective as earplugs if  you don't play audio in my experience. I like the   wing shape, which helps them sit flush in your ear  without falling out. The material feels like very   soft silicone, and they do feel much softer in  your ears than earbuds with solid plastic shells.   They come with three different wing sizes as well  as seven different sizes and styles of tips. Some   supposedly increase airflow while others block  more noise, but I haven't noticed much difference   between them, to be honest. It's great that there  are so many sizes though, and both my partner and   I have managed to get a really good fit with them.  Changing the wings and tips is a bit fiddly, but   it's worth experimenting with the different sizes  to get the most comfortable and effective seal.  There's also a very short USB-C to USB charging  cable and an easy-to-understand instruction   manual. All in all, they look good out of  the box, with enough options to customize   them for your ears. One big plus with the A20s  is the really long battery life. I found that   as long as you don't use them extensively  during the daytime as well, you just don't   need to worry about them dying during the night.  When fully charged, the earbuds will apparently   last up to 14 hours in sleep mode or 10 hours  in Bluetooth mode at moderate volume levels,   and you get up to 80 hours total time with the  additional charge in the case, which is great.   You can also see the battery life of each earbud  in the app, which is very useful. I streamed   continuous music from Spotify on my phone at 50%  volume during the day and got just over 9 hours   from one charge. The battery life for the case  is so long that I don't particularly worry about   this though. As long as I remember to charge it  once a week, the earbuds never seem to die on me.  Okay, let's talk about the Soundcore app now,  which is great in many ways because it has so   many useful features but can be a little bit  frustrating to use at times. The main thing   to understand is that there are two main modes:  Bluetooth mode and sleep mode. In Bluetooth mode,   you can play any audio you like through your  device, so it's great that you can use other   relaxation apps, YouTube, or Spotify, for example.  In Bluetooth mode, you can also browse and select   which sleep sounds you want in sleep mode. You can  see that my library here only has three sounds,   with a maximum of four that you can currently  send to your earbuds to use in sleep mode. And in   the sounds, there's a range of presets and custom  options to build your own. You can combine three   of them, such as rain, river, and crickets, and  I found this helps make the short loops on less   constant sounds less noticeable. You can also  adjust the volume of all three independently and   then use the tune sounds feature, which I really  like. And actually, it makes a huge difference   to the way they sound - it's not a subtle change  at all. This feature comes up later in my noise   masking tests because I found 'soft' makes the  sounds bassier and therefore better at blocking   snoring. Once you've chosen your sounds, you  can transfer them to your earbuds, and then   when you go into sleep mode, you can listen to  them and even turn your phone off if you like.  There are a couple of other key features to note  here. Firstly, you can stream your own audio and   use Smart Switch to change to the sleep sounds  when you fall asleep, but since I don't trust   the sleep tracking, I don't bother with that.  You also have Smart Volume, which adjusts the   volume automatically as the earbuds' microphone  picks up changes in the bedroom audio, but again,   I don't use that because I prefer a more constant  volume. So the app has some great features,   but it does take a bit of getting used to, and I  think it's a shame that one of the best features,   the equalizer, is hidden behind several button  presses. I experimented with all the sleep   sounds and various weird combinations like the cat  drinking, singing bowls, and keyboard. In the end,   the one I've used most nights is just the  spaceship. It's kind of like a distant fan   sound in a cave, and I just really like the sound. For me, the best point about the Soundcore Sleep   A20 is that they manage to balance being  comfortable enough to use in bed with   audio quality that's more than good enough for  bedtime listening, and actually, better than   previous sleep headphones I've used. To give you  a better idea, here you can see them compared to   the Philips sleep headphones with Kokoon, which  I'll refer to as Philips Kokoon in this video,   the Quieton 3.1, which are no longer sold but  were also very small, and the Apple AirPods   Pro 2. The AirPods Pro 2 are the only ones with  active noise cancellation and audio, and you can   see the difference in size that the extra tech  creates. The Philips Kokoon were previously the   most comfortable sleep earbuds I'd tried, so it's  interesting that the shape and interchangeable   wings concept is so similar. And here you can  see them with my favorite foam earplugs, which   themselves are on the smaller side. To compare the  comfort, I spent a week wearing each option and   gave them a score out of 10 when lying on my back  or on my side and front with different pillows.   You can see in this table that on my back, I gave  the A20, SleepPhones, Quieton, and foam earplugs   a 9 out of 10. On my side with a soft feather  pillow, the A20, Philips Kokoon, SleepPhones,   and earplugs all got a 9. On my side or front with  a firmer memory foam pillow, though, the earplugs,   SleepPhones, A20, and Philips all got an 8 out  of 10. Overall, the foam earplugs, SleepPhones,   and A20 came equal first with 26 out of 30  points, but earplugs obviously can't play music,   so that just leaves the SleepPhones matching the  A20 for comfort as a like-for-like comparison.  So despite my test, it's important to  remember that comfort is a subjective thing,   and you might not have the same experience as  me. I have quite large ears and ear canals,   and I find that the A20s fit quite snugly inside,  but even I have to make some small adjustments to   the angle of my head sometimes when I lie on my  side, particularly if I'm using a firmer pillow.   Compared to bulkier headphones, though, I think  it's very easy to find a comfortable position.   But if you have very small or sensitive ears or  a very firm pillow and sleep a lot on your side,   it's possible you'll find them less comfortable. Okay, let's talk about the audio side of the A20s.   Personally, I was really surprised by how good  they sound considering they were made specifically   for sleep, but I do think it's relative to what  you're used to. For example, if you listen to   high-end headphones or a speaker system during the  daytime and then you suddenly switch to the A20,   you're going to notice a drop in overall quality.  For example, compared to my Sony WF-1000XM4,   the bass isn't as punchy or rounded, and music  lacks a bit of warmth. However, if you're   listening to more basic speakers or, you know,  normal headphones, not really high-end headphones,   and then you suddenly switch to these at night,  then I think you're going to be pleasantly   surprised by how good they sound. And perhaps  most importantly, the audio quality is better   than any other sleep headphones I've tested. One  caveat is that I didn't test the discontinued Bose   Sleepbuds 2 or the Ozlo, but they definitely sound  better than the SleepPhones, the Philips Kokoon,   the Cozyphones, MaxRock, Dubslabs Bedphones,  and all the other budget sleep headbands I've   tried. And by better, I mean more bass, richer  sound, clearer mids and highs, and more volume   than all of those. I also did some different  tests to see how well they mask external noise   without active noise cancellation, as well  as how well they compare to other headphones   and foam earplugs. For the first test, I tried  different sleep sounds on the app as well as some   brown noise from YouTube to try and mask moderate  snoring. I played a snoring track next to me in   bed through the Soundcore Boom 2 Plus Bluetooth  speaker and set the volume so that it peaked at   55 decibels. You can see in this table that with  no audio at all they don't block much snoring,   but I was able to completely block the snoring in  various different ways, shown as a 10 out of 10.   I had the best results from combining multiple  sounds such as snoring mask 1 and 2 along with   brown noise. I could also completely block  it using my own brown noise track on YouTube.  For the second test, I turned the volume up to  a level that would be considered severe snoring,   peaking at 65 decibels. This time it was  impossible to completely mask the snoring without   playing audio at a volume that would be hard to  sleep with and probably bad for your hearing. The   closest I got to a tolerable level was combining  the train and brown noise, tuning it to soft and   turning the volume up to 80%, but even that was  hard to listen to for long. Unfortunately, the   reality is that severe snoring right next to you  in bed is incredibly difficult to fully block out.  In my third test, I played some electronic  music in the room next door quite loudly.   This was easier to block out than the severe  snoring, and I was able to do so with various   different app sound combinations and volume  levels. The brown noise and train tuned soft   or double rain both worked well, for example. In test 4, I played lighter snoring and tested   multiple app sounds at a reasonable volume of  50%. Personally, I could listen to any of these at   that volume level. Again, I found that combining  sounds such as the airplane and spaceship was the   most effective way to block the snoring. In my final test, I played some songs   and a podcasts to see which would mask snoring  peaking at 60 decibels. At a tolerable volume   level for me of 70%, none of them completely  blocked it, though a few songs got close such   as "Saltwater" by Chicane. Interestingly, all the  songs but neither podcast completely blocked the   snoring at maximum volume, but again it was too  loud to listen to. So I think the key takeaways   from my audio test are that even without the  active noise cancellation, with the right   audio choice, you can use the A20s to block out  light to moderate snoring and music from another   room. For severe snoring, you might be able to  take the edge off but probably not block it out   completely. And importantly, the bass was better  than other sleep headphones and so it did a better   job of blocking out noise than those did. As for the noise isolation, in case you're   wondering, it's actually really good. I also asked  my partner to have a listen when I was playing   different songs, and she said she couldn't hear  anything unless I had the volume turned right up,   which I don't generally do in bed anyway. One  of my biggest criticisms of the Soundcore Sleep   A20 is that the sleep tracking doesn't seem very  accurate. I think probably the biggest issue is   that they only use an accelerometer to infer  your sleep stages and there's no heart rate   monitor. And for me, they make the classic mistake  of thinking that you're asleep when you're just in   bed lying still. For example, on this particular  night, if you compare the data of my Eight Sleep   Pod 3 cover with the Soundcore Sleep A20, you can  see the A20 say I fell asleep at 10:54. The Eight   Sleep correctly recorded that I was awake  in bed though and didn't fall asleep until   11:37. So if the sleep tracking is unreliable,  it means that the Smart Switch feature and the   Audio Timer are going to be a bit hit or miss. So  personally, I don't use the Smart Switch feature,   and for the Audio Timer, I either set it to  two hours or for the whole night, and that   seems to more than make up for the fact that  it doesn't really know when I'm falling asleep.   Other issues with the sleep tracking are that  there's only deep sleep recorded, no REM sleep,   and there's no trends over time. But that makes  sense because if you take the earbuds out in the   middle of the night, it only records two or three  hours sleep, for example. The only sleep tracking   points I did like were the times you roll over  and the percentage spent in one position, but even   those aren't particularly useful as I already know  I sleep on my right side and sometimes roll over   in the night. So personally, I don't use the sleep  tracking. I wouldn't miss it if it wasn't there,   and I'm just glad that you can fully enjoy the  audio without the sleep tracking. And there is   part of me that wonders whether it would have  been better to completely ignore sleep tracking   and just focus on the comfort and the audio,  which they do so well anyway. So yeah, maybe   there would also be some extra space for some more  files in the sleep mode rather than just the four.  Okay, let's run through a few other points to  note about the Soundcore Sleep A20. I think the   alarm feature is very useful; it's always good to  have an alarm that doesn't wake your partner up,   but it obviously relies on you wearing them  all night. I like how you can customize the   controls and have a different control on each  earbud with a double or triple tap. However,   I personally just have them set to turn the volume  up or down with a double tap because I find the   triple tap too fiddly and it doesn't always work.  I really like how well they stay in your ear; mine   haven't fallen out once during the month I've used  them. The Bluetooth connection seems very stable,   and I've had no problems with it. I also like  how my sleep audio automatically plays when I   take them out of the case at bedtime, and it's  great that you can turn your phone off if you   want to and just listen to the sounds stored  on the earbuds. They seem relatively robust,   and actually even though there's no waterproof  rating, I dropped my right earbud in a glass   of water 2 weeks ago and after drying it with a  hair dryer and leaving it for a couple of days,   it's been fine. Obviously, I don't know if it  will slowly degrade over time and just conk   out one day, but for now, it seems to have  survived. The Find Device is a really useful   feature. If they do fall out, you can make each  earbud beep independently to find them. I really   like the custom EQ, which is great if you want  to boost the bass of your music, for example.   You can also use it to try and mask external  noise that's disturbing you more effectively.  As for the price, at the time of filming, they  cost £119.99 in the UK and $149.99 in the US,   for example. While more expensive than some  standard headphones, they are more affordable than   high-end headphones and also less than the Philips  Kokoon and similar to the SleepPhones Effortless.  Okay, before I give you my final verdict, let's  have a quick look through the main pros and cons   as I see them. Starting with the pros, they're  comfortable to wear all night in any sleep   position. The audio quality is very good for sleep  headphones. They have excellent battery life. You   can stream your own audio. The customizable white  noise and nature sounds mask external noise well.   They have a stable Bluetooth connection or  an offline sleep mode with your phone off,   and there are useful extra features like tap  controls and Find Device. As for the cons,   there's no active noise cancellation. Changing the  wings and tips can be fiddly. The sleep tracking   is unreliable, mistaking being still with asleep  sometimes. You can only store four audio files   at a time in sleep mode and none of your own  audio, and the app is a bit confusing to use.  My final verdict then is that the Soundcore Sleep  A20 strike a really good balance between comfort,   audio quality, features, and value for money. I  think if comfort in different sleep positions is   your main priority when choosing sleep headphones,  then these are as good as it gets at the moment,   with the exception of maybe one or two of the  headband styles which are also comfortable to   wear in bed. As I said at the beginning though,  for earbuds, it's very rare that I can wear them   all night long considering I spend so much time  on my side or my front. Compared to other sleep   headphones and many regular headphones, the audio  quality is surprisingly good. While they don't   match high-end headphones, they deliver clear  sound and enough bass to enjoy a wide range   of music genres, ambient sounds, and podcasts in  bed. As for the lack of active noise cancellation,   if that's what it takes for them to  be this small with current technology,   I'm okay with that. I found they're capable  of masking a lot of external noise with the   customizable sleep sounds or your own audio  anyway, so I don't really miss the ANC in bed,   but I can see why some people would prefer to  have ANC. So overall, if you're looking for   headphones specifically to use in bed, I think the  Soundcore Sleep A20 are definitely worth a shot.  And that's it for the review. I hope you found  it useful. If you did and you'd like to find   out more or buy a pair, I'll put a link in the  description below. And please also subscribe   to my YouTube channel to keep in touch and see  future videos. Thanks for watching, sleep well.