⚖️

Church and Legal Case Overview

Jun 20, 2025

Overview

Andrew Haines, a youth pastor at Fox River Lutheran Church in Illinois, has been indicted on multiple felony child sex abuse charges but remains listed as a staff member months after his arrest. The alleged incidents involve a girl under 13, and church and Haines have so far not provided substantive public comment.

Arrest and Charges

  • Andrew Haines was arrested on November 9, 2023, for five felony counts: four of predatory criminal sexual assault and one of aggravated criminal sexual abuse.
  • The charges relate to alleged abuse of a girl under 13 in October 2019 and from late August to late September 2023.
  • Haines has pleaded not guilty and was released on home confinement.

Employment and Church Response

  • Haines remains listed as a staff member at Fox River Lutheran Church as of publication.
  • He has served as both youth pastor and music director for several years.
  • The church and other staff have not responded to repeated requests for comment from the media.
  • Haines, using a church email, requested information on who tipped off the reporter but did not comment further.

Timeline and Background

  • Haines first preached at Fox River Lutheran Church in November 2019 and was listed as youth pastor as of September 2020.
  • He is also a musician and has performed at church events alongside other Christian artists.

Legal Proceedings and Media Coverage

  • Several local news outlets reported on Haines’s arrest, but did not mention his church employment.
  • A status hearing for Haines’s criminal case is scheduled for April 19 in LaSalle County Circuit Court.

Community and Public Reaction

  • Comments reflect debate over presumption of innocence, church transparency, and journalistic standards.
  • Some commenters criticize the church for not updating Haines’s employment status; others stress due process and privacy.

Key Dates / Deadlines

  • November 9, 2023: Andrew Haines arrested.
  • April 19, 2024: Status hearing scheduled for Haines’s criminal case.

Questions / Follow-Ups

  • Will Fox River Lutheran Church make a public statement or update Haines’s staff status?
  • What will be the outcome of the April 19 court hearing?
  • Will further details of the case or internal church actions be disclosed?