Circumcision: Rite Faces Modern Concerns

Overview

• A long-standing Jewish tradition where baby boys are circumcised, often performed through a religious ceremony known as a bris.
• The practice dates back to the biblical times of Abraham, as a covenant with God.
• The article explores the modern debate and concerns surrounding circumcision within the Jewish community.

Key Points

The Religious Significance of Circumcision

• Circumcision is a key religious ritual for Jewish identity, commanded by God in the Bible.
• Dr. Steven Adashek emphasizes its importance as the second most important commandment in the Torah, after "Be fruitful and multiply."
• The procedure is typically performed on the eighth day after birth.
• Involves a religious ceremony where family and friends gather to witness the ritual.

Personal Experiences

• Example of Bram Goldstein, whose parents embraced the ceremony as a meaningful connection to their faith and tradition.
• Emphasis on not causing pain to the baby; modern practices include using local anesthesia.
• Parents describe a sense of spiritual transcendence during the ceremony.

Growing Concerns and Alternatives

• A small but increasing number of Jewish parents are questioning the necessity of circumcision.
• Concerns include the potential pain and risks associated with the procedure.
• Some parents consider alternatives, such as the Brit Shalom, a Jewish welcoming ceremony without circumcision.

Case Study: Susan Peckham and Daniel Abraham

• Susan, a convert to Judaism, and Daniel are ambivalent about circumcising their expected child.
• They grapple with the decision, balancing religious history with concerns for their child's welfare.
• They are considering Brit Shalom as an alternative, which is gaining popularity among some Jewish families.

Social and Family Pressures

• The decision to not circumcise can lead to familial tensions, with some grandparents feeling strongly against omitting it.
• Rabbi Binyamin Biber, who conducts Brit Shalom ceremonies, notes the challenge of addressing these issues within families.

Conclusion

• The practice of circumcision in Judaism is deeply rooted in religious tradition, but modern concerns are prompting some families to reconsider.
• The decision involves navigating religious obligations, familial expectations, and modern medical and ethical considerations.

Related Topics

• The article is part of NPR's "Beginnings" series which explores culture and traditions related to pregnancy and childbirth.