Analysis of Janelle Monáe's "Turntables"

May 3, 2025

Turntables by Janelle Monáe - Analysis

Introduction

  • Janelle Monáe is a notable American artist known for her work in music, film, and activism.
  • "Turntables" is a protest song written for the 2020 documentary All In: The Fight for Democracy.
  • The song addresses voter suppression and other social inequalities.
  • The track was nominated for an Oscar in 2021.
  • Monáe has her own independent label, Wondaland Arts Society, and is signed to Sony Music Publishing.

Context of "Turntables"

  • Part of the documentary focusing on the 2018 Georgia Governor elections, highlighting voter suppression tactics.
  • 1.4 million minorities were removed from the electoral roll, and many were incorrectly deemed ineligible to vote.
  • Music video serves as a platform to address social inequalities in America and globally.

Media Language

Codes and Conventions

  • Performance/Narrative Hybrid: Monáe sings directly to the camera, engaging the audience.
  • Protest Song Elements: Strong beat akin to a march, uplifting chorus typical of power ballads.
  • Visual and Technical Codes:
    • Clothing: Diverse cultural representations.
    • Iconography: Includes literal interpretations of lyrics, e.g., turntable imagery, symbolic gestures.
    • Expressions and Gestures: Replicate iconic protest imagery such as the Black Power salute.
    • Camera and Editing: Techniques like canted angles and fast cuts create a sense of urgency and a call for change.
    • Audio: Includes voice clips like James Baldwin’s speech on racial challenges.

Narrative Structure

  • Non-linear: Combines past, present, future elements.
  • Direct Address: Engages audience with direct storytelling.
  • Theme: Emphasizes change and revolution with recurring lyrics like "tables about to turn".

Representation

Gender and Ethnicity

  • Monáe challenges stereotypes, presenting minorities as powerful rather than subordinate.
  • Positive Representation: Uses cultural iconography to convey hope and empowerment.

Theoretical Approaches

  • Semiotics (Barthes): Deep meanings through signifiers like the American flag.
  • Structuralism (Levi-Strauss): Recognizable structure of music videos used to convey social messages.
  • Representation (Hall): Avoids stereotypes, promotes positive representation.
  • Feminist Theory (Van Zoonen) and bell hooks: Engages with ideas of feminism as political commitment, not just lifestyle.
  • Postcolonial Theory (Gilroy): Challenges colonial attitudes and emphasizes unity over cultural differences.

Social, Cultural, and Political Context

  • Reflects contemporary issues like voter suppression, Black Lives Matter, and inequality.
  • Audience Engagement: Different audiences may respond based on their social and cultural contexts.
  • Alludes to recent political events and movements, such as George Floyd protests and immigration policies.

Conclusion

  • "Turntables" by Janelle Monáe serves as a powerful commentary on social issues, using the music video medium to advocate for change and empower under-represented groups.