🏥

Restraints and Reform in Aged Care

Apr 28, 2025

Lecture on Aged Care, Dementia, and the Use of Restraints

Overview

  • Discussion centered on the issues of physical and chemical restraints in aged care facilities.
  • Highlighted specific cases and expert opinions on the matter.

Case Study: Terry Reeves

  • Background: Terry Reeves had Alzheimer's diagnosed at 60, was in a nursing home in Sydney.

    • Daughter Michelle McCullough found him restrained in a chair, often left alone.
    • Restraints used frequently, sometimes up to 14 hours a day.
  • Consent and Medication:

    • Family consented only if Terry was a danger, but felt it was overused.
    • Suspected use of antipsychotics as chemical restraints.
    • Discrepancy found in medical charts vs. pharmacy bills.
  • Policy Changes:

    • Nursing home claimed policy changes made post-incident.

Expert Opinions

  • Mary Burgess: Queensland public advocate comments on lack of regulation.

    • Argues that using restraints without legal framework is a breach of human rights.
  • Professor Henry Brad Daugherty: Authority on dementia.

    • Highlights lack of consent issues in antipsychotic usage in nursing homes.
    • Survey found minimal written consent for antipsychotic prescriptions.

Case Study: Margaret Barton

  • Background: Margaret given sedatives at two Victoria nursing homes.

    • Dosage increased excessively, leading to physical decline.
  • Consequences:

    • Experienced multiple falls, leading to rib and pelvic fractures.
    • Died of pneumonia, medication regime contributed to her decline.

Industry Practices and Recommendations

  • Current Practices:

    • Some nursing homes have improved practices without extra costs.
    • Change in attitude and practice rather than financial investment.
  • Need for Regulation:

    • Australia lacks a framework for aged care restraint practices.
    • Research indicates restrictive practices harm older people.

Personal Accounts

  • Impact on Families:
    • Loss of abilities noted in elderly post-restraint.
    • Families express concern over accelerated decline.

Conclusion

  • Urgent need for better alternatives and reform in aged care practices.
  • Cases highlight the system's potential to cause harm.

Reflection

  • Families and experts call for systemic change to prevent future harm.
  • Importance of balancing care with humane treatment in nursing homes.