Kafka vs RabbitMQ: Stream Processing vs Message Queuing

Introduction

• Distributed Systems Misconception: Kafka and RabbitMQ are not interchangeable, they serve different purposes.

Kafka: Stream Processing System

• Design:
  • Handles streams of events.
  • High throughput.
  • Messages remain until expiration.
  • Fan-out by default (each consumer gets a copy).
• Use Case:
  • Suitable for distributing events to multiple independent services.
  • Useful for logging, data analytics, real-time updates.

RabbitMQ: Traditional Message Queue

• Design:
  • Manages message queuing until processing.
  • Supports complex message routing.
  • Message destined for one consumer.
  • Handles moderate data volumes.
• Use Case:
  • Ideal for processing messages with dedicated processors.
  • Efficient in distributing messages to processors/replicas.

Consumer Patterns

• Kafka: Fan-out model (all consumers receive all messages).
  • Useful for events needing distribution to multiple services.
• RabbitMQ: Messages routed to one consumer per message.
  • Efficient for scalable processing systems with many replicas.

Message Routing

• Kafka:
  • Producer handles routing using topics and partitions.
  • High scalability due to reduced cluster workload.
  • No post-production control on message routing.
• RabbitMQ:
  • Uses exchanges to route messages.
  • Allows consumer control over message consumption.

Suitability

• Kafka:
  • Ideal for uniform, low-cost processing messages.
  • High throughput and fan-out scenarios.
  • Real-time data streaming and logging.
• RabbitMQ:
  • Best for long-running, unpredictable task durations.
  • Handles complex routing and sporadic data flow.

Acknowledgement

• Kafka:
  • Uses offsets instead of acknowledgements.
  • Consumers fetch new data from last read offset.
  • Suitable for batch processing small events with some tolerance for message drop.
• RabbitMQ:
  • Uses explicit acknowledgements.
  • Waits for acknowledgement before re-routing unacknowledged messages.
  • Better for long-running tasks that need confirmation of completion.

Recap: Use Cases

• Kafka:
  • Stream data analysis, event bus model.
  • Logging, real-time communication.
• RabbitMQ:
  • Job worker systems, decoupling microservices.

Additional Resources

• More in-depth learning available at interviewpen.com
• Join their Discord for questions and further learning.