Overview
The speaker compares the Apple Watch Ultra to the Garmin Fenix 7X after six months of use, analyzing their strengths for different usage scenarios. They conclude that neither device fully replaces the other and share their current approach and recommendations for various fitness and daily needs.
Initial Impressions and Shift in Perspective
- Initially doubted the Apple Watch Ultra could replace the Garmin Fenix for fitness and sports tracking.
- Apple Watch Ultra gradually became the daily watch due to its smart features.
- Recognized Apple’s smartwatch as genuinely useful for athletes, not just casual users.
Comparative Analysis: Garmin Fenix 7X vs. Apple Watch Ultra
- Garmin Fenix 7X remains the superior sports watch, especially for tracking and long-distance events.
- Apple Watch Ultra offers features Garmin lacks, such as phone capabilities, texting, and music streaming, making it very functional as a daily smart device.
- Both watches excel at particular tasks, and the decision depends on individual priorities and use cases.
Use Cases and Preferences
- Garmin is preferred for events requiring reliable tracking (e.g., extreme distance, harsh weather).
- Apple Watch Ultra is ideal for routine runs, gym sessions, or when phone functionality is desired without carrying a phone.
- Sometimes chooses not to wear any smart device for simple, tech-free enjoyment of exercise (“naked running”).
- Uses a regular notebook for tracking lifting workouts instead of digital features.
Thoughts on Tracking and Data Overload
- No longer feels the need to track every fitness metric or use every device feature.
- Finds joy in exercising without constant monitoring, inspired by others who have also abandoned obsessive tracking.
Data Management and Device Integration
- Uses TrainingPeaks as a central platform to collate cardio data from Apple Watch, Garmin, Zwift, and EXR.
- Considers it liberating to not be tied to a watch 24/7.
Current Recommendation and Decision
- Still recommends Garmin Fenix for best-in-class sports tracking, especially for long-distance events.
- For overall versatility and smart functions, the Apple Watch Ultra is the best choice if only one device is possible.
- Currently splits usage: about 50% Apple, 20% Garmin, remainder with traditional watches or no watch.
Feature Requests and Final Remarks
- Would like Garmin to add mobile network capabilities, and for Apple to make their watch look sportier.
- No sponsorships from Apple or Garmin influenced these opinions.
- Open to changing preferences in the future as new devices or needs emerge.