Freud's Analysis of Little Hans' Case

Apr 22, 2025

Lecture Notes: Freud's Case Study of Little Hans

Overview

  • Little Hans is a pseudonym for Herbert Graf, born in 1903 in Vienna.
  • Son of Max Graf, a Viennese music critic and follower of Freud.
  • Little Hans' case was primarily documented through letters between his father and Freud.

Key Events and Symptoms

  • Traumatic Event: At age 4, Hans witnessed a horse collapse, leading to a fear of horses, especially those with certain features (e.g., black around the eyes, wearing blinkers).
  • Genital Preoccupation: Hans was curious about male genitals, calling it his "widdler."
  • Sibling Jealousy: After the birth of his sister, Hans exhibited jealousy and wished harm upon her.

Freud's Interpretation

  • Oedipus Complex: Freud interpreted Hans' fears and fantasies through this lens.
    • Hans' fear of horses symbolized fear of his father, whom he saw as a rival for his mother's affection.
    • The horse's black features were seen as representing his father's moustache and spectacles.
    • Hans had fantasies of having children with his mother, viewing his father as a grandfather.
    • Dreams and fantasies were interpreted as reflections of conflict between desire for the mother and fear of the father.

Treatment Process

  • The father worked with Freud's guidance to analyze Hans' behavior and dreams.
  • Freud only met Hans once; most of the case study was conducted through correspondence.

Criticisms of the Case Study

  • Bias and Influence: Max Graf’s prior knowledge of Freud’s theories may have influenced the interpretation.
  • Generalizability: The study lacked population validity, as it was based on one individual.
  • Hans' Retrospective View: As an adult, Hans did not recall his childhood discussions and viewed his case history as unfamiliar.

Conclusion

  • The case of Little Hans is often cited as evidence of the Oedipus complex but has been criticized for methodological weaknesses.
  • Freud used the case to support his broader theories of childhood development.

  • Recommendations: For more case studies and Freud's analysis, explore other lectures or watch videos on similar topics.