⚖️

Understanding UCC 2-718 on Damages

Apr 24, 2025

UCC 2-718: Liquidation or Limitation of Damages; Deposits

Overview

  • Purpose: Addresses the conditions under which damages for breach of contract may be liquidated or limited in a sales agreement.

Key Points

1. Liquidation of Damages (Subsection 1)

  • Conditions: Damages can be liquidated in the agreement if:
    • The amount is reasonable in relation to the anticipated or actual harm.
    • Takes into account the difficulties of loss proof and the feasibility of obtaining an adequate remedy.
  • Limitation: Terms fixing unreasonably large liquidated damages are void as a penalty.

2. Buyer's Restitution (Subsection 2)

  • Entitlement: If the seller justifiably withholds delivery due to buyer’s breach, the buyer may get restitution of payments exceeding:
    • (a) The amount to which the seller is entitled per liquidated damage terms, or
    • (b) 20% of the value of the total performance or $500, whichever is smaller, if no terms exist.

3. Offset against Buyer's Restitution (Subsection 3)

  • Seller's Claims: Seller can offset buyer's restitution if:
    • (a) Seller has a right to recover damages under other provisions of the Article.
    • (b) The buyer received any benefits from the contract.

4. Payment in Goods (Subsection 4)

  • Treatment of Goods: Goods received by the seller as payment are treated as payments per subsection 2.
  • Resale Conditions: If the seller knows of the breach before reselling the goods, the resale must comply with conditions in Section 2-706 for resale by an aggrieved seller.

Important References

  • Section 2-706: Details conditions for resale by an aggrieved seller.
  • Related Definitions: Agreement, Seller, Buyer, Goods, Contract.

Implications

  • Contracts: Ensures fairness in liquidating damages and provides mechanisms for restitution and offset.
  • Enforcement: Prevents abuse of power in setting liquidated damages by voiding unreasonable terms.