🚂

Mojang Snapshot: Redstone and Minecart Changes

Aug 18, 2024

Mojang Snapshot Overview

General Changes

  • Mojang released a snapshot focused on bundles.
  • Discontent among the Redstone community due to changes in mechanics.
  • Extensive changelog covering various aspects such as Redstone, Minecart updates, and baby animals.

Redstone Changes

Minor Changes

  • Redstone Torch Texture
    • Updated texture; improved aesthetics.

Major Changes

  • Directional and Locational Changes
    • Introduction of randomness into Redstone behavior:
      • Left lever activates left piston, right lever activates right piston.
      • Middle lever results in random activation.
    • Previously, Redstone behavior was consistent but directional and locational:
      • Activation would yield different results based on direction.
      • Examples of locational differences causing issues.
    • New behavior allows for more unpredictability in builds.

Randomness Across Time

  • Control over activation timing but randomness introduced:
    • Example with pistons and honey blocks demonstrating the behavior changes based on lever placement.
    • Priority for north/south pistons over east/west in certain setups.

Theoretical Implications

  • Changes primarily affect builds that were already locational, leading to potential debugging challenges.

Minecart Changes

Major Rework

  • New mechanics allow Minecarts to arc and fly.
  • New game rule: Minecart Max Speed set to 8 blocks/s by default, can be increased to 1,000 blocks/s.
    • Allows for creative and entertaining Minecart setups.

Controversial Changes

  • Minecart Stacking Removal

    • Previously allowed stacking on a single rail; now causes issues in builds.
    • Dispensing multiple Minecarts leads to broken mechanics.
  • Minecart Alignment Changes

    • New alignment mechanics make it difficult to set up certain designs (e.g., piston bolts).
    • Buggy behavior observed with placement in powdered snow.

Summary of Minecart Changes

  • Inspector Talon suggests revisions in his in-depth video.
  • Overall, new system requires tweaks for improved performance.

Redstone Component Updates

  • QC (Quick Charge) Changes
    • QC properties affected for components like pistons, sticky pistons, droppers, and dispensers.
    • Important for powering components from unexpected locations, leading to flexibility in Redstone builds.
    • Current changes disrupt many common setups, causing widespread concern among Redstone users.

Breaking Changes

  • Many existing Redstone contraptions may fail due to removal of QC functionality.
  • Examples of setups that will break due to the lack of block updates from Redstone Dust.
  • Introduction of the Copper Bulb as a potential workaround for updates.

Community Response

  1. Fix Your Stuff
    • Criticism of the community suggesting to adapt to broken systems.
  2. Easier Redstone
    • Casual players believe changes simplify Redstone but may not attract new creators.
  3. Mojang Knows Better
    • Community disagreement with Mojang's approach; emphasizes need for feedback.

Conclusion

  • Call to action for Mojang to listen to Redstone community feedback.
  • Importance of understanding the impact of changes on existing Redstone functionality.