What is This Weapon? Lecture Notes
Introduction
- Host: Jonathan
- Focus: G11 Rifle, one of the rarest firearms.
- Significance: Advanced Combat Rifle (ACR) designed to potentially replace the M16 A2 in the late 1980s/1990s.
Overview of the G11
- Nearly final iteration, G11 ACR.
- Serial number mismatch indicates assembly from two different ACR program rifles.
- Provided by another collection for the episode.
- Contributions from World of Guns for visual demonstrations.
Historical Context
- Early Development
- Initial concepts from Nazi Germany in the 1930s.
- First modern caseless ammunition developments in 1959 (US) and 1961 (Germany).
- HK began collaborating with Dynamit Nobel in 1967.
- Prototype Development
- Early bullpup designs.
- Focus on lightweight, high rate of fire, and closed system for dirt protection.
- 1970s: Various prototypes, development of a drum breach and caseless ammunition.
Design and Features
- Structure
- Polymer casing with steel components.
- Integral optic with elevation control.
- Magazine moves with the barreled action.
- Mechanics
- Recoiling barrel action within a sealed casing.
- Rotary drum mechanism for chambering and firing rounds.
- Complex trigger mechanism for semi, auto, and 3-round burst.
- Firing System
- Caseless ammunition advantages: lower weight, smaller volume.
- Capable of 2,100 rounds per minute 3-round burst.
- Issues with magazine loading and durability.
Challenges and Limitations
- Technical Issues
- High complexity and difficulty in understanding and assembling.
- Heat issues: risk of cook-off, evaporation of lubricant.
- 3-round burst recoil issues.
- Subpar trigger pull and cocking handle weakness.
- Logistical and Operational Concerns
- Reloading challenges due to magazine design.
- Maintenance issues with lead fouling and 3,000 round chamber life.
- NATO standardization issues and German political decisions.
Trials and Testing
- American ACR Trials
- ACR trials in the late 1980s; no rifle met hit probability improvements needed.
- G11 did not achieve the hoped-for revolution.
- German Involvement
- Bundeswehr trials in parallel with ACR program.
- G11 formally adopted briefly before being dropped due to funding.
Conclusion: Pros and Cons
- Pros
- Lightweight, low recoil, increased hit probability.
- Technological advancements in caseless technology.
- Cons
- Complexity, high maintenance, logistical and operational challenges.
- Ultimately not feasible for military deployment.
Final Thoughts
- Despite potential, caseless ammunition for military rifles is considered impractical.
- HK's financial struggles and eventual buyout by Royal Ordnance.
- G11 remains a historical curiosity rather than a practical military weapon.
These notes summarize the key points from the lecture on the G11 rifle, covering its development, features, challenges, and historical significance.