Overview
This is a detailed account of the murder of Patrick De La Cerda, the investigation that followed, and the trial of his killer, Gregory Bender. The narrative traces the events from the discovery of the crime, through the investigation, to the conviction and sentencing of Bender.
The Murder and Initial Response
- On February 27, 2018, Patrick De La Cerda was shot and killed at his home just before receiving a custom engagement ring for his fiancée, Jessica Devnani.
- Police arrived at the scene, secured the property, and determined the killer was no longer present.
- Jessica and Patrick's father, Max, were interviewed, revealing Patrick had anticipated a delivery that day after receiving a suspicious phone call.
Investigation and Key Findings
- No valuables were missing, ruling out robbery; spent shell casings indicated a planned murder using .300 Blackout ammunition.
- Surveillance DVR was stolen, suggesting the killer wanted to avoid being identified.
- Jessica revealed ongoing threats from her ex-boyfriend, Gregory Bender, who had previously harassed and stalked her.
- Despite a restraining order and apparent cessation of contact, Bender called Jessica on the morning of the murder.
Developing the Case Against Gregory Bender
- Jessica assisted police in a recorded call with Bender, but he did not incriminate himself.
- Bender was arrested for violating the restraining order to prevent evidence destruction while police sought further proof.
- Bender’s wife, Daymara Sanchez, provided police with Bender’s notebook outlining a murder plan, which matched details of the crime.
Critical Evidence and Arrest
- Police searched Bender’s home and found the written murder plan, .300 Blackout ammunition, and a spent shell casing matching those at the crime scene.
- Surveillance footage placed Bender leaving his home before the murder and traveling to Patrick’s house.
- Ballistics confirmed the shell casing from Bender’s home matched the crime scene, establishing a direct link.
The Trial
- The murder trial began in May 2021, based primarily on circumstantial and physical evidence.
- Bender’s defense attempted to discredit Jessica using secretly recorded videos, but she explained the context of threats and manipulation.
- Testimony from Bender’s ex-wife confirmed the existence and intent of the murder plan.
- The prosecution presented evidence of premeditation, surveillance, and Bender’s actions before and after the crime.
Verdict and Aftermath
- The jury found Gregory Bender guilty of first degree murder, resulting in an automatic life sentence without parole.
- Patrick’s family and Jessica found some closure with the verdict, honoring Patrick’s memory and their love.
Action Items
- TBD – Authorities: Continue to support Jessica and Patrick’s family and ensure compliance with sentencing.
- TBD – Jessica: Preserve Patrick's memory and live life as he would have wanted.