Overview
This episode covers the true-crime case of the Maguad family murders in the Philippines in December 2021, detailing the events leading up to and following the murders, the background of those involved, the investigation, and the subsequent legal and community responses.
The Maguad Family and Janice's Adoption
- The Maguad family consisted of parents Cruz and Lavella, and biological children Gwen and Louis.
- Gwen and Louis persuaded their parents to adopt Gwen’s friend Janice, believing she needed stability and a home.
- Janice was taken in, legally adopted, and treated equally as family, including school enrollment and household responsibilities.
- The family dynamic initially improved after working through early trust issues, including Janice stealing money due to a scarcity mindset from her past.
Events of December 10, 2021
- Both parents left for work, leaving Janice, Gwen, and Louis at home.
- Janice hid under her bed and texted for help, claiming masked men broke into the house and attacked her siblings.
- Her father returned home to find two children dead; Janice was found wet, having taken a bath after the incident, citing panic.
- Evidence at the crime scene (multiple possible weapons, excessive wounds) did not support the theory of a simple burglary.
Investigation and Public Reaction
- Initial theories of robbery and family land disputes were discarded due to lack of supporting evidence.
- Suspicion grew around Janice due to inconsistencies, her behavior (taking a bath, delayed calls for help), and digital activity during the event.
- Police found an unfamiliar ID in Janice’s room, belonging to "Marlon," a 17-year-old later linked to the crime.
- Janice confessed involvement in the murders with Marlon, her accomplice, after police questioning.
Motive and Psychological Analysis
- Janice was not an orphan; she maintained contact with her biological mother.
- Speculated motives include jealousy, desire for sole affection, and possible deeper psychological and systemic issues.
- Text messages revealed Janice expressed homicidal fantasies and indifference toward killing, challenging initial theories about her motivations.
Legal Proceedings and Sentencing
- Janice and Marlon, both minors, were sentenced to a combined term of about 32 years without parole for the two murders, sparking public outrage over the perceived leniency.
- The Maguad parents advocated for judicial reform and forgiveness but ultimately struggled when confronted with Janice’s lack of remorse.
Aftermath and Community Response
- The Maguads opened a restaurant, Casa M M, in remembrance of their children.
- The case contributed to public debate on juvenile justice, adoption, and system failures in child welfare.
Decisions
- Adopt Janice: The Maguad family decided to legally adopt Janice after their children's request.
- Open Casa M M: The parents opened a restaurant in memory of Gwen and Louis.
Action Items
- TBD – Authorities: Review and address gaps in child welfare and adoption procedures.
- TBD – Legislators: Re-evaluate juvenile sentencing and criminal responsibility laws in light of public concern.
Questions / Follow-Ups
- What was the true extent of Marlon's involvement and his relationship with Janice?
- How did Janice’s background and systemic failures contribute to the crime?
- Could stronger oversight have prevented the adoption misclassification?