Lecture Notes: Discussion on The Good Doctor and Autism Representation

Introduction

• Therapist recommended watching "The Good Doctor" to feel better about autism diagnosis.
• The show portrays an autistic surgical resident, Sha Murphy (US version) / Park Schion (Korean version).
• Mixed feelings about the show and its representation of autism.

Overview of The Good Doctor

• American medical drama based on South Korean "Good Doctor."
• US version popular, adapted in multiple countries.
• Central scene discussed: "I am a surgeon" meme from Season 2.

Criticisms and Discussion of Autism Representation

• Critics claim show features stereotypical behaviors rather than a full portrayal.
• Portrayals considered exaggerated and offensive by some.
• The character's emotional outbursts seen as unrealistic by critics.
• Critics argue character is a hodgepodge of autistic stereotypes.

Positive Reception by Some Viewers

• Some autistic viewers find Sha relatable and see themselves in him.
• Provides comfort and representation, especially in professional settings.

Character Background and Development

• Sha Murphy's traumatic past: abusive father, loss of brother.
• Foster system experience, motivated by a toy scalpel from brother.
• His path to becoming a surgeon, supported by Dr. Glassman.
• Experiences ableism at hospital but succeeds due to savant skills.

Key Episodes and Scenes

• Episode 16, Season 5: Participation in a reality show; concerns about public perception of autism.
• Meltdown Scene (Season 2): "I am a surgeon" becomes a meme, showcases Sha’s emotional breakdown.
• Character Arc: Growth from fear of abandonment to valuing relationships.

Critique of Hollywood's Autism Portrayal

• Criticism of hiring non-autistic actors for autistic roles.
• The show’s casting and consultation decisions questioned.
• Autism Speaks involvement considered controversial.

Other Autistic Characters

• Several other autistic characters in the show, mostly played by autistic actors.
• Various portrayals show different aspects of autism.

Issues with Show's Messages and Writing

• Over-reliance on savant stereotype; unrealistic memory portrayal.
• Misrepresentation of medical facts, especially in sensitive episodes (e.g. trans representation).
• Critiques of lazy or shallow writing, sensationalizing issues.

Personal Reflection and Conclusion

• The show is seen as aspirational, but unrealistic portrayal of autistic experiences.
• Importance of nuanced representation and use of autistic actors discussed.
• While the show has issues, some viewers find it relatable and comforting.
• Encouragement to support authentic autistic creatives for better representation.