⚔️

Exploring Fullmetal Alchemist Adaptation Challenges

Apr 25, 2025

Next Gen FM-ABR Episode Breakdown: Episode 1

Introduction

  • First of a video series offering a behind-the-scenes look into episode production.
  • Core ingredients: Fullmetal Alchemist 2003 and Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood.
  • Project hinges on the way these series split the manga.
  • Seven story fragments not adapted sufficiently are to be revived.

Adaptation Challenges

  • 2003 Deviations:
    • Introduced new, darker themes (e.g., bird chimera, homunculi from human transmutation).
    • Rearranged plot (e.g., reordering backstory, train battle).
    • Added lore (e.g., Lior as a desert).
  • FM-ABR Goal: Closer to manga than official cuts, but includes beneficial elements from 2003.

Technical Aspects

  • Aspect Ratios:
    • 2003: 4x3 full screen standard.
    • Brotherhood: 16x9 widescreen standard.
    • Options to resolve discrepancy: Pillarboxing, letterboxing, cropping, and retrofitting.

Audio and Video Composition

  • Audio Tracks:
    • 2003 series English and Japanese audio, mixed to align with Brotherhood.
    • Post-production audio adjustments for language differences.
  • Video Tracks:
    • Hard-coded subtitles for reference, 4x3 and 16x9 footage.
    • Modification tracks for reframing and lipflap edits.

Episode Breakdown: Lior

  • Deviates from Brotherhood by beginning with Ed and Al's human transmutation.
  • 2003 vs. Manga Introduction:
    • 2003 provides more detailed setting visuals.
    • Key deviation: Removal of original narration in favor of later series dialogue.

Scene Decisions

  • Kept Lior as a desert, using 2003's setup.
  • 2003 Scenes Kept:
    • Red wine fountain, religious broadcasts, Cray's attack.
    • Rose's confrontation with truth enhanced by additional sources (FMA Mobile, FMA2, Kakao FMA).
  • FMABR Edits:
    • Reframed shots, lip flap edits to match audio and visual consistency.
    • Manga panels used for missing animations.

Conclusion

  • Episode 1 is a complex undertaking involving multiple sources to faithfully adapt the manga.
  • Successful integration of 2003 and Brotherhood materials enhances the narrative.
  • Next episodes: Mining Town and Battle on the Train.