🧙

History and Impact of Papal Prediction Markets

Mar 14, 2025

The Original Prediction Market Was Betting on the Pope - Odd Lots

Introduction

  • Hosted by Tracy Alloway and Joe Wisenthal.
  • Discussion on prediction markets, which are platforms for betting on various outcomes, from politics to social events.

Concept of Prediction Markets

  • Serve as an interesting news filter and gauge of public opinion.
  • Not always about being right or wrong but understanding differing opinions.
  • Question of social value: Do financial incentives improve prediction accuracy?

Historical Context: Papal Prediction Markets

  • Early example in Renaissance Rome: betting on the next pope.
  • Renaissance Rome had a significant market around papal elections.
  • Papal bulls like "Colgetos" banned betting on papal elections in 1591 with excommunication as a punishment.

Participants in Early Papal Betting

  1. Gentlemen's Bets
    • Aristocrats and cardinals made side bets.
  2. Brokers (Sinsally)
    • Took bets from all social classes.
    • Often connected to the Florentine financial industry.
    • Popular bets included outcomes of papal elections and sports.
  3. Financial Institutions
    • Engaged in risk hedging and political risk coverage.
    • Papal elections impacted taxation and political changes in the Papal states.

Gambling Culture in Renaissance Rome

  • Longstanding tradition of gambling on various events.
  • Driven by politics and foreign interests.
  • Rumors and insider information influenced odds.
  • Attempts at market manipulation, e.g., false rumors affecting odds.

Impact and Regulation by the Church

  • The Catholic Church perceived betting as a threat.
  • Enforcement of bans was inconsistent due to internal Vatican links.
  • Crackdowns in late 1500s; severe penalties introduced.
  • Papal bull "Colgetos" aimed to nullify all bets and excommunicate offenders.
  • Gambling seen as undermining church's authority and leading to unethical practices.

Evolution of Papal Betting Markets

  • Markets declined post "Colgetos" but resurged in the 19th and 20th centuries.
  • Modern betting on popes began in UK in 1978.
  • Recent papal elections saw substantial amounts bet, though prediction market accuracy was mixed.

Modern Implications and Discussion

  • Current prediction markets exist for many topics, including potential new popes.
  • Discussion on societal acceptance of gambling and its limits.
  • Legalization increased ease of access, impacting betting culture.
  • Debate over the societal utility of prediction markets remains.

Conclusion

  • Prediction markets provide a lens into public opinion but have complex social, ethical, and financial implications.
  • The future of prediction markets in society is uncertain, with ongoing debates about their role and regulation.

Hosts and Contributors

  • Tracy Alloway and Joe Wisenthal host the podcast.
  • Guest: Ryan Izako, author of the "No Dumb Ideas" substack.
  • Discusses history and impact of papal prediction markets.