🧠

Exploring the Controversial History of Lobotomy

Apr 25, 2025

Lobotomy Lecture Notes

Introduction to Lobotomy

  • Lobotomy (also known as leucotomy) is a controversial neurosurgical procedure once used to treat psychiatric and neurological disorders like depression and epilepsy.
  • Involves severing connections in the brain's prefrontal cortex.

Historical Context

  • Originated by Portuguese neurologist António Egas Moniz, who won the 1949 Nobel Prize for the development of leucotomy, despite later controversy.
  • Popularity grew in the 1940s and 1950s, with nearly 20,000 procedures performed in the US by 1951.
  • More commonly performed on women; criticized for its effects on personality and intellect.

Procedure and Techniques

  • Initially involved drilling holes in the skull; evolved into the transorbital lobotomy using an icepick-like instrument.
  • Walter Freeman promoted the transorbital lobotomy, making the procedure more accessible and notorious for its simplicity and speed.

Controversy and Decline

  • Criticized for severe side effects, including reduced personality complexity, emotional blunting, and various postoperative complications (e.g., seizures, incontinence).
  • The Soviet Union banned lobotomy in 1950 on ethical grounds.
  • Development of antipsychotic medications led to a decline in lobotomy's popularity.
  • Viewed today as a symbol of medical barbarism and a violation of patients' rights.

Legal and Ethical Considerations

  • Many countries and US states banned the procedure by the 1970s.
  • Nobel Prize awarded to Moniz remains controversial and has been criticized by modern scholars.

Cultural Impact

  • Lobotomy has been depicted in literature and film, often negatively, influencing public perception.
  • Notable cases include Rosemary Kennedy and the play "Suddenly, Last Summer" by Tennessee Williams.

Summary

  • Lobotomy is largely discredited today, remembered for its historical significance in psychiatric treatment and its ethical implications.