⚖️

Understanding the US Court System Hierarchy

Jan 10, 2025

Crash Course Government and Politics: The US Court System

Introduction

  • Host: Craig from Crash Course
  • Mention of hierarchy: Craig at the top, followed by John Green, Stan, Brandon, Zulia, etc.
  • Comparison of hierarchy in Crash Course HQ to the US court system

Hierarchical Structure of the American Court System

  • Trial Courts:

    • Have original jurisdiction
    • State Courts: Majority of cases start here; 50 states each with their own system
    • Federal Courts: U.S. District Courts (94 courts, 663 judges)
    • Civil cases can start in state or federal court if certain criteria are met
    • Most criminal cases start in state courts
  • Appeals Courts:

    • If dissatisfied with trial court results, appeals can be made
    • State courts often have two levels of appellate courts
    • Federal system has one level
    • Federal appeals courts are called circuit courts (12 in total)
    • Appeals typically heard by panels of three judges

Federal Court Jurisdiction

  • Original Jurisdiction:
    • Federal law is at issue
    • Cases involving treaties
    • U.S. Constitution-related cases
    • U.S. government as a party
  • Interstate Cases:
    • Cases involving parties from different states with more than $70,000 at issue

The Supreme Court

  • Appellate Jurisdiction:
    • Final court of appeals
    • Exercises judicial review
  • Original Jurisdiction:
    • Cases between U.S. and a state
    • Cases between two or more states
    • Cases involving foreign ministers or ambassadors
    • Crimes committed on the high seas
  • Case Selection for the Supreme Court:
    • Only about 80 decisions per year from 8,000 requests
    • Requires case or controversy and standing
    • Avoids advisory opinions
    • Cases must not be moot (require resolution)
    • Must be ripe (actual potential injury)
    • Political Question Doctrine: May defer to executive or legislative branches
    • Circuit splits: Conflicting lower court rulings
    • Federal government appeals
    • Clear constitutional questions

Conclusion

  • Next episode: What happens when a case reaches the Supreme Court
  • Production credits and support information

  • Note: The humorous tone of the presentation, with jokes about suing Switzerland and Craig's hierarchical position, enhances engagement but does not detract from the educational content.