Chapter 3: The First U
Chapter 3: The First U.S. Erection: Foundations of a Republic
---
Introduction
The inaugural election of the United States, held in the early months of 1789, stands as a foundational moment in American history. This chapter examines the circumstances, key figures, and implications of this event, offering a lens through which to view the fledgling republic’s earliest democratic processes. Unlike today’s elections, this first exercise in republican governance was a blend of innovation and continuity, deeply influenced by both Enlightenment ideals and the practical realities of post-revolutionary America.
---
Context: A New Government Framework
The election of 1789 followed the ratification of the United States Constitution in 1788, a document that replaced the faltering Articles of Confederation. The Constitution established a federal government with three branches: legislative, executive, and judicial, designed to provide checks and balances. Central to this framework was the creation of the office of the President, a position absent in the Articles and reflective of a more centralized authority.
While the Constitution outlined the broad structure of governance, many specifics were left to be interpreted and implemented. The Electoral College system, devised as a compromise between popular sovereignty and elite control, became the mechanism by which the President and Vice President were to be chosen. This system, though familiar today, was an untested innovation in 1789, fraught with uncertainties and potential for factional disputes.
---
The Candidates: George Washington’s Uncontested Ascendancy
The election of 1789 was unique in that it featured no real contest for the presidency. George Washington, revered as the hero of the American Revolution and a unifying figure among the states, was the near-universal choice. His reluctance to seek power only enhanced his appeal, as it aligned with the republican virtue of selfless public service. Despite this near-consensus, the election was still an important exercise in legitimizing the new government through a formal process.
Electors were selected by state legislatures in most states, with only a few opting for a popular vote. Each elector cast two votes for President, and while Washington was the clear choice for the first vote, the contest for the second-highest total—and thus the Vice Presidency—revealed early partisan divisions. John Adams emerged as the Vice President, a role initially seen as a subordinate and somewhat undefined office.
---
Mechanics of the Election: The Role of the Electoral College
The election of 1789 offers a glimpse into the early workings of the Electoral College, a system that reflected both the republican ideals and the federalist concerns of the time. Each state was allotted a number of electors equal to its total representation in Congress (House + Senate). However, given the incomplete ratification of the Constitution and logistical challenges, only ten of the thirteen states participated in this first election. North Carolina and Rhode Island had not yet ratified the Constitution, and New York failed to appoint electors in time due to internal political disputes.
Electors convened in their respective states on February 4, 1789, to cast their votes. Communication was slow, and it wasn’t until April 6, 1789, that a quorum was reached in Congress to count the electoral votes. The process underscored the nascent government’s challenges in coordinating national activities across vast and varied territories.
---
Key Outcomes and Significance
George Washington was unanimously elected as the first President of the United States, receiving all 69 electoral votes. This unanimity not only reflected his personal stature but also the widespread desire for unity in a nation still healing from revolutionary tumult. John Adams, with 34 votes, became Vice President, marking the beginning of a working relationship between two figures with differing political philosophies.
The election set several precedents that would shape future contests. It demonstrated the flexibility and resilience of the new constitutional system, even in its infancy. Additionally, the peaceful transfer of power—although uncontested in this instance—laid the groundwork for future democratic stability.
---
The Road Ahead: Challenges for the First Administration
While the election was a success, it was merely the first step in the monumental task of nation-building. Washington’s administration faced numerous challenges: establishing a functioning executive branch, managing foreign relations, stabilizing the economy, and addressing regional tensions. The legitimacy conferred by this election was crucial as Washington and his colleagues sought to translate constitutional ideals into practical governance.
In retrospect, the first U.S. election was as much a symbolic affirmation of republican ideals as it was a procedural innovation. It demonstrated the capacity of the American people to adapt European traditions of governance to their unique context, inaugurating a system that would evolve but endure.
---
Conclusion: The First Election as a Democratic Experiment
The election of 1789 was an experiment in applying the principles of democracy and republicanism to a new nation. It reflected both the aspirations and limitations of the time. While George Washington’s unanimous selection might suggest an absence of true competition, the very act of holding an election marked a profound shift toward institutionalized democratic governance. As we delve deeper into the early republic, this election remains a touchstone for understanding the political culture and foundational moments of the United States.
---
**Discussion Questions**:
1. How did the Electoral College reflect the compromises and tensions of the Constitutional Convention?
2. In what ways did George Washington’s election set precedents for future presidential elections?
3. Consider the roles of unity and consensus in the early republic. How did these ideals shape the first election?