🌀

Understanding Revolutions: Definitions and History

May 2, 2025

Revolution: Key Concepts and Historical Overview

Definition and Core Elements

  • Revolution: A rapid, fundamental transformation of a society’s class, state, ethnic, or religious structures.
    • Latin origin: revolutio, meaning 'a turnaround'.
  • Common elements:
    • Efforts to change political regimes with a vision of a just socio-economic order.
    • Informal and formal mass mobilization.
    • Socio-economic and political change through actions like demonstrations, protests, strikes, and violence.

Historical Occurrences

  • Revolutions vary in methods, durations, and outcomes.
  • Can start from peasant uprisings, guerrilla warfare, or urban insurrection.
  • Inspired by ideologies such as nationalism, republicanism, socialism, etc.
  • Vulnerability factors:
    • Military defeat, economic chaos, national pride affronts, repression, corruption.
  • Typically trigger counter-revolutions.

Notable Revolutions

  • American Revolution (1765-1783)
  • French Revolution (1789-1799)
  • Haitian Revolution (1791-1804)
  • Spanish American wars of independence (1808-1826)
  • Revolutions of 1848
  • Mexican Revolution (1910-1920)
  • Xinhai Revolution (1911)
  • Russian Revolution and German Revolution (1917-1919)
  • Chinese Communist Revolution (1927-1949)
  • Decolonization of Africa (1950s-1975)
  • Algerian War of Independence (1954-1962)
  • Cuban Revolution (1959)
  • Iranian Revolution and Nicaraguan Revolution (1979)
  • Revolutions of 1989
  • Arab Spring (early 2010s)

Etymology and Evolution of the Term

  • 13th-century French noun revolucion, 14th-century English 'revolution': celestial bodies' motion.
  • Mid-15th century: abrupt social change.
  • 1688: "Glorious Revolution" - political regime change.
  • Now often denotes social and political institution changes.

Definitions by Scholars

  • Jeff Goodwin:
    • Broad: Overthrow and transformation by irregular or violent popular movements.
    • Narrow: Includes mass mobilization, regime change, and fundamental social/economic/cultural change.
  • Jack Goldstone:
    • Emphasizes transformation of political institutions and authority.
    • Excludes peaceful transitions or coups not transforming institutions.

Typologies of Revolution

  • Alexis de Tocqueville: Sudden and violent vs. slow and relentless revolutions.
  • Marxist Typology: Pre-capitalist, early bourgeois, proletarian, and socialist revolutions.
  • Charles Tilly: Coup d'état, civil war, revolt, great revolution.
  • Mark Katz: Six forms, including rural, urban, coups, revolutions from above, etc.

Social Revolution Examples

  • Industrial Revolution: Technological transformation.
  • Scientific Revolution: Advances in knowledge.
  • Commercial Revolution: Economic changes.
  • Digital Revolution: Digital transformation.

Studies and Theoretical Approaches

  • First Generation: Descriptive, social psychology focus (e.g., crowd psychology).
  • Second Generation: Frameworks based on psychology, sociology, political theories.
  • Third Generation: Marxist class-conflict approach; state, elite, lower-class conflicts.
  • Fourth Generation: Quantitative techniques, broader structural theories, contentious politics.

Contemporary Critiques and Developments

  • Recognition of diverse revolutionary forms beyond class struggles.
  • Integration with studies of social movements for enriched understanding.
  • Development of new datasets for empirical analysis.

Cultural and Institutional Considerations

  • Revolutions as "liminal" moments, akin to rituals.
  • Douglass North's caution on revolutionary rhetoric vs. real institutional change.

Additional Insights

  • Revolutions can also denote significant changes outside politics, e.g., cultural or technological transformations.