The New Deal and Opposition

Jul 26, 2024

Chapter 26 Part Two: The New Deal and Opposition

Overview

  • Focus: Roosevelt's New Deal attempts to fix the Great Depression.
  • Billions spent; unemployment starts to drop.
  • Roosevelt faces opposition within his own party.

Key Figures of Opposition

Huey Long

  • Background: Populist from Louisiana, controlled Louisiana's politics.
  • Beliefs: Against oil companies, and banks; promised free textbooks for poor children.
  • Share Our Wealth Program:
    • Confiscate fortunes over $5 million.
    • 100% tax on incomes over $1 million.
    • Redistribution to provide houses, cars, necessities, and $2,000-$3,000 annual income for the poor.
    • Assassinated in 1935.
  • Impact: FDR feared his independent run might harm democratic votes.

Father Charles Coughlin

  • Background: Catholic priest with popular radio shows on social/political issues.
  • Criticisms:
    • Believed Roosevelt didn't go far enough.
    • Supported inflated currency, attacked New Deal, and farm programs.
    • Accused government of being sympathetic to communists and Jewish people.
  • Organization: National Union for Social Justice.

Dr. Francis Townsend

  • Proposals:
    • Mandatory retirement at 60 to open jobs for younger people.
    • $200 monthly pension for those 60+, must be spent within 30 days to stimulate economy.

Second New Deal (1935)

  • Business groups oppose Roosevelt.
  • Roosevelt becomes pro-labor, anti-business.

Key Legislation

  • National Labor Relations Act (Wagner Act):
    • Rights to collectively bargain.
    • Prohibited employer interference in unions.
    • Outlawed company unions.
    • Set up National Labor Relations Board to supervise union elections.
  • Social Security Act of 1935:
    • Old age pensions starting at 65.
    • Initially excluded agricultural workers, domestic help, and self-employed.
    • Provided federal unemployment assistance.
  • Rural Electrification Administration (REA):
    • Provided low-rate loans to extend electricity to rural farms.
    • Increased rural farm electrification from 10% (1935) to 90% (1950).

Roosevelt's Overreach and Opposition

  • Supreme Court Conflict:
    • Roosevelt’s plan to add justices for overworked judges over 70 backfired.
    • Plan was seen as a move to disrupt separation of powers; lost public trust.
  • 1938 Political Backlash:
    • Republicans gained seats in Congress.
    • Anti-New Deal coalition formed.
    • Difficulty in passing legislation post-court packing plan.

Economic Decisions

  • Unemployment Decrease: From 25% to 14% by 1937.
  • Budget Cuts: Reduced federal spending in the 1938 budget.
  • Fair Labor Standards Act (1938):
    • Minimum wage: 25 cents/hour, increasing to 40 cents/hour in two years.
    • Maximum workweek: 44 hours, reducing to 40 hours in two years.
    • Banned oppressive child labor.

Legacy of the New Deal

  • Economy:
    • Failed to significantly reduce unemployment or increase middle-class movement.
    • Large expansion of federal bureaucracy.
    • Increased expectations of federal government intervention in crises.
  • Women and Minorities:
    • More women appointed to federal positions, e.g., Frances Perkins as Secretary of Labor.
    • African Americans switched to the Democratic Party, but Roosevelt did little for civil rights.
    • Native Americans benefited from the Indian Reorganization Act of 1934.

Impact on Government and Society

  • Government Supervision:
    • Increased federal control over stock exchange, agriculture, and labor relations.
  • Social Attitudes:
    • Shift in public expectation for federal government to address national welfare issues.
  • Lobbyist Growth: Significant increase in lobbying activity.

Roosevelt’s Foreign Policy and Prelude to WWII

  • Isolationism: Roosevelt forced to adopt isolationist policies as tensions rise in Europe.
  • Neutrality Acts: Restricted U.S. involvement, even refusing aid to invaded nations.
  • Undeclared War:
    • Roosevelt’s policies indirectly supporting Allied efforts, e.g., convoy protections and seizing Greenland and Iceland.
    • Incidents like the sinking of USS Reuben James escalated U.S. involvement.

Conclusion

  • Prelude to War: Roosevelt's efforts set the stage for eventual U.S. involvement in WWII.
  • Transition: Next chapter will focus on the build-up to and the outbreak of WWII.