Key Themes in Crime and Punishment's Part Three

Aug 17, 2024

Crime and Punishment - Part Three Overview

Chapter 1

Key Characters and Plot Points

  • Raskolnikov: Struggles with his moral decisions and illness, forbids Dunia from marrying Luzhin.
  • Dounia (Dunya): Raskolnikov’s sister, considered marrying Luzhin for her brother’s sake, but faces a dilemma.
  • Luzhin: Viewed as obnoxious by Raskolnikov, believes poor women will be indebted and subservient to their husbands.
  • Razumikhin: Tries to keep the peace, convinces the women to give Raskolnikov space, and is attracted to Dounia.
  • Zosimov: The doctor brought by Razumikhin to check on Raskolnikov; believes his illness has both mental and physical causes.

Themes and Analysis

  • Moral Conflict: Raskolnikov gives Dounia an ultimatum: choose between Luzhin and him.
  • Trust and Relationships: Despite Razumikhin’s drunken state, the women trust him.
  • Illness: Raskolnikov’s condition is influenced by poverty, anxiety, and moral ideas.

Chapter 2

Key Events

  • Razumikhin and Zosimov: Discuss Raskolnikov’s situation, suspect the police's involvement may have exacerbated his condition.
  • Luzhin's Letter: Threatens to leave if Raskolnikov is present at his visit, falsely accuses Raskolnikov of giving away money to a morally questionable girl.

Character Analysis

  • Luzhin: Revealed as vain, shallow, arrogant, and manipulative, using threats to control Dounia.
  • Dounia’s Dilemma: Wants Raskolnikov present during Luzhin’s visit; faces pressure to choose between her brother and Luzhin.

Themes

  • Manipulation and Control: Luzhin attempts to manipulate Dounia by threatening her relationship with her brother.
  • Family and Loyalty: Dounia is caught between loyalty to her brother and the pressures from Luzhin.

Conclusion

  • The chapter ends with Dounia, Pulcheria, and Razumikhin setting off to check on Raskolnikov, highlighting the ongoing concern for his well-being and the tension within family and social relationships.