🍇

Social Suffering of Oaxacan Berry Workers

Apr 22, 2025

Oaxacans Like to Work Bent Over: The Naturalization of Social Suffering among Berry Farm Workers

Overview

  • Author: Seth M. Holmes
  • Published by: Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
  • Award: 2006 Rudolf Virchow Award
  • Focus: Examination of the social suffering and structural violence experienced by Oaxacan berry farm workers in the Skagit Valley, Washington.

Geographic and Economic Context

  • The Skagit Valley, Washington State is agriculturally significant with a history of family farming now threatened by agribusiness and urban development.
  • The Tanaka Farm is a key location, employing hundreds of migrant workers primarily from Oaxaca, Mexico.

Migrant Workers' Living Conditions

  • Migrant workers often live in poor conditions: shacks with inadequate insulation and facilities.
  • Conditions include overcrowded, unsafe, and unclean environments, contributing to physical and mental health issues.

Ethnic and Citizenship Hierarchies

  • Labor is segregated based on ethnicity and citizenship, creating a hierarchy:
    • Top: Anglo and Asian-American citizens
    • Middle: Latino American citizens or residents
    • Bottom: Undocumented Indigenous Mexicans (Mixtecos and Triquis)
  • This hierarchy dictates job roles, with Triqui people often assigned the most strenuous, low-paid work.

Fieldwork Insights

  • Fieldwork Methodology: Participant observation, interviews, and engagement with the community over 15 months.
  • Holmes lived and worked alongside Triqui workers, observing firsthand the exploitation and hidden suffering in the camps.
  • Engaged with workers across different locations, including their hometowns in Oaxaca and during border crossings.

Structural and Symbolic Violence

  • The labor hierarchy is a form of structural violence resulting in unequal suffering, health issues, and exploitation.
  • Symbolic violence involves the internalization and naturalization of social inequalities based on perceived bodily differences.
  • Workers often justify their harsh conditions through ethnic pride and perceived physical resilience.

Health and Medical Context

  • Migrant clinics often fail to address the social determinants of health, focusing instead on biological and behavioral factors.
  • Clinicians may unintentionally blame patients for their health issues, not seeing the broader social context of their suffering.

Resistance and Naturalization

  • While open resistance is rare due to fear of reprisals and deportation, workers use subtle forms of resistance within their constraints.
  • Hierarchical oppression is often seen as natural due to symbolic violence, preventing effective challenges to the status quo.

Implications for Change

  • Pragmatic solidarity is needed to denaturalize social inequalities, involve pickers in community programs, and educate health professionals about social determinants.
  • Policy changes should address the economic and political determinants of migration and labor conditions, promoting fairness and equality.

Conclusion

  • The article calls for a combined academic and activist effort to address the root causes of social inequality in agriculture and support migrant workers in achieving better living and working conditions.

View note sourcehttps://learn-us-east-1-prod-fleet02-xythos.content.blackboardcdn.com/61b0bc96c4ba2/3000338?X-Blackboard-S3-Bucket=learn-us-east-1-prod-fleet01-xythos&X-Blackboard-Expiration=1745323200000&X-Blackboard-Signature=FdhOz2yJkQlY83aeHXDoqJ3IR3nfX7ZFmp9KmxbZ6UA%3D&X-Blackboard-Client-Id=304354&X-Blackboard-S3-Region=us-east-1&response-cache-control=private%2C%20max-age%3D21600&response-content-disposition=inline%3B%20filename%2A%3DUTF-8%27%27Holmes%2520-%2520Oaxacans%2520Like%2520to%2520Work%2520Bent%2520Over%2520The%2520Naturalization%2520of%2520Social%2520Suffering%2520among.pdf&response-content-type=application%2Fpdf&X-Amz-Security-Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEEYaCXVzLWVhc3QtMSJIMEYCIQDI0nZL7a9fR%2FKm5SIVb2Z%2FSuzg8EeGeD26953LQzpDZwIhAPNnGf8d4%2FlvZ5g8ZOIHN3JeAh%2B%2F8tIzKP50GLoqgRcVKrwFCM7%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2FwEQBBoMNjM1NTY3OTI0MTgzIgzPwGWd5meUFYs%2BHS8qkAW8g5KGaNAN%2FTi1mBKkqE54XZ7cf%2BsQktKjWj8IcIvMytOQE%2F9Tkz8nQKMb4ZVw6bh4c5e%2FUonk%2FsYNZCf0OV7PXVc%2BunkBdtj6WQ9BCPjl7gBI7JkG43%2F%2FxJ8DMnvJ6kZJqKmTkb03Bmnnd1QsiQeReSCnC0%2BYgE1JN8x%2BpU0%2FnJmFAdb6wyRWk6Gzj%2BhazpZIxc3hHKLeN5WkrWWhRwkz8fFzgr5%2BFh1SaRdqBNX6pkefP%2BwBcdku%2F8OsLK%2BdRF4nuRk91SoZQ3sqrAnCCxZO0Fn%2BYqjm0%2B6ZXrfFArgjXo5bmhD3d1EmcxFblj5ZLBMfwsmr2bor9FwnmaEpljpF2%2BGBPCnN4gmsJGkH6T%2B8j3rOVZJ0fXKz5pS3I69GKvP4ach6hB7486tG%2BCDki1215Upa2BCkjt4XkXzv5Dihcw8CmvqqZsjE1k40mGWun%2Fzau525suaaVX5vLc5fhDZ2mSOL4%2BDxYODGvGXN3%2BSFkUB1Wgjpo7HnRKE3dRqsMK%2Brc1lHSTAJN4AXfxAuCXDj6%2FCntjJr2ct8K%2BMK6YjCHMyUags6JTWrvG8PzN95WwQnokY18GBCvHlB1Tj%2BdkYpUDBq99iE%2B4B5MzW%2FbiJVC%2FlsFeh%2BJBs7HpxhgtYHqyTTfMRos2q68KXhzjO6eMyZ3U9wQgPGrMFDUfOof4ajMKitnnzORoTURhIR9YFJNXNm0427%2F0mN58iE1LLOyVsvYjmuzZsHLuF%2BNYPHWbq2qqmjDZJ4rtxeX7nE9uFOlgoQClwNodchirTkL0gNwwBccRuhNb%2BGXqcfuV7B9kHpvfz8TYPB2K8WNwVVp9N2ldE%2FLLLz5gXzEInGi4usOK1r5zxnYSrkW268JDFVYvGRHDCXzZzABjqwAYF%2BXviE%2FlNAP4uS38bTusdTWKLPN1ERZE50l%2BoE5dJQv44MZzCmPR0plRy4vCRSKVsM7JbNy45USoCpbZDZEgQ9GHv8Uo73NNn24Fi3cdC4QnmyDyt%2BEIDf91y8wbT68TEAqBw69M7pBDnLjjoj3wG9V0O2B8i%2Fgz6I6XWPBt1t2og%2Fk3l1wm9mvOlBNzrA5GVY7gMgV6LzzOnGA0CpamYO0%2BGFc1rUPFMOOFS0lOCG&X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Date=20250422T060000Z&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Expires=21600&X-Amz-Credential=ASIAZH6WM4PLUEZKAITG%2F20250422%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Signature=83dd12afbbb4a08633e062ad4b562dacc8b08d5bedba61ec4ca52bf634804f48