Lecture on BMI and Ideal Body Weight

May 19, 2024

Lecture on BMI and Ideal Body Weight 🍎

Key Concepts

Normal vs. Healthy

  • Obesity in America: Becoming the norm but not healthy.
  • Underweight in Santa Monica: Common but also not healthy.
  • Miss America BMI Trends: Historically within a healthy range (20-22 BMI), but trends have shifted:
    • 1920s: Healthy BMIs (~21-22)
    • 90s-2000s: Very slim became popular
    • Now: More muscle, leading to slightly higher BMIs

Norm vs. Healthy

  • Norm does not equal healthy.
  • Most people in the US are obese or overweight; this is the norm but associated with higher disease risk.
  • Focus: Preventing disease rather than body shaming.

Calculating Ideal Body Weight Using the Hamley Equation

Hamley Equation Overview

  • Origin: From the 1950s, used in clinical settings.
  • Formula for males:
    • Base: 106 lbs at 5 feet
    • +6 lbs per additional inch
  • Formula for females:
    • Base: 100 lbs at 5 feet
    • +5 lbs per additional inch

Example Calculation

  • 5'2" Female:
    • 5 feet: 100 lbs
    • +2 inches: 10 lbs
    • Ideal Body Weight: 110 lbs

Frame Size Adjustment

  • Bracelet Method:
    • Use thumb and middle finger to form a bracelet around the wrist of the non-dominant hand.
    • Small Frame: Fingers overlap
    • Medium Frame: Fingers touch
    • Large Frame: Fingers do not touch
  • Adjustment:
    • Small frame: Subtract 10% from Ideal Body Weight
    • Medium frame: No adjustment
    • Large frame: Add 10% to Ideal Body Weight

Example Adjustment

  • 5'2" Female, Small Frame:
    • Ideal Body Weight: 110 lbs
    • Adjustment: -11 lbs (10% of 110 lbs)
    • Range: 99 - 110 lbs

Wrist Measurement Method

  • Measure wrist circumference about an inch below wrist bone.
  • Compare wrist measurement to height (both in cm).
  • Provide a more precise frame size classification than the bracelet method.
  • Action Items:
    • Measure wrist
    • Calculate frame size
    • Compare results with bracelet method for consistency

Note: Always validate the frame size result with better measurement methods if possible.