Rousseau’s Civilization and Morality Critique

May 22, 2024

Jean-Jacques Rousseau and His Ideas on Civilization and Progress

Introduction

  • Modern life closely connected with the idea of progress
  • 18th century: Belief in humanity's positive developmental path
  • Jean-Jacques Rousseau contradicts this view

Jean-Jacques Rousseau's Background

  • Born in 1712 in Geneva
  • Father was an educated watchmaker
  • Family had to leave Geneva due to a legal dispute
  • Instability and loneliness in Rousseau's life
  • Moved to Paris, confronted with the luxury of the Ancien Régime

Insight and Central Thesis

  • 1749: Reading the newspaper "Mercure de France" raises the question of progress
  • Rousseau had an epiphany: Civilization and progress harm morality
  • Thesis: Civilization leads to moral decline

Writings and Arguments

Discourse on the Sciences and Arts

  • Individuals were originally good and happy
  • Union in societies leads to vices

Discourse on the Origin and Basis of Inequality Among Men

  • Idea of the "state of nature"
  • People lived reasonably, loved family, respected nature, showed empathy
  • State of nature characterized by morality and spontaneous compassion

Critique of Civilization

  • Civilization awakens unhealthy self-love ("amour propre")
  • Pride, envy, and vanity dominate
  • People constantly compare themselves and lose sense of their own feelings

The Noble Savage

  • Term "noble savage" remains associated with Rousseau
  • Contrast: Innocence and morality of ancestors vs. modern decadence
  • European fascination with North American tribes

Interest in Natural Goodness

Emile, or On Education (1762)

  • Children born "naturally good"
  • Education should protect against social corruption
  • Influential idea: child-centered education
  • Promotion of breastfeeding

Novels and Autobiography

  • Novel "Julie" (1761): Celebration of intense feelings vs. social conventions
  • Autobiography "Confessions": Exploration of the inner life

Later Influences

  • Died in 1778, reputation continued to grow
  • Hero of the French Revolution
  • Influence on 19th-century artists and writers
  • Founder of Romanticism: Appreciation of the primitive, the child, and the passionate lover

Conclusion

  • Modern world remains deeply romantic, influenced by Rousseau's ideas