Police Response to Neighbor Dispute

Initial Encounter

• Officer arrives at a scene involving a dispute between neighbors.
• Officer aggressively threatens one individual: "Don’t make me come in that house... I’ll tase you."
• Officer escalates situation quickly and pulls out a taser.

Situation Background

• Individual named Cadon Lachlan was transporting a developmentally disabled client to his home.
• Neighbor dispute with off-duty police officer, Andrew Carter.
• Conflict started over a dog that ran onto Officer Carter’s property.
• Words were exchanged between Cadon and Carter.

Police Report vs. Actual Events

• Carter’s report: Cadon made hostile comments and aggressive gestures.
• Cadon’s lawsuit: Carter threatened him and the minors with his firearm.
• Cadon did not display any weapon; was calm and compliant.
• Misrepresentation by Carter and his colleagues.
• Carter allegedly placed his hand on a firearm during the conflict.

Officer Roy Stasher's Actions

• Verbally abusive and aggressive upon arrival.
• Threatens to use taser without learning facts.
• Does not document Cadon’s claim that Carter threatened him first.
• Charges Cadon with aggravated assault and reckless endangerment.

Aftermath

• Criminal defense attorney intervenes; media exposes the case.
• Charges against Cadon are dropped after media coverage.
• Police chief's statement: Charges inappropriate, officer receives minor discipline.
• Cadon files a civil lawsuit; settlement terms undisclosed.

Constitutional Rights

• Fourth Amendment: Protects against unreasonable searches and seizures.
• Arrest lacked probable cause, no immediate safety threat.
• Officer behavior deemed unreasonable and aggressive.

Public Exposure and Accountability

• Public outrage influenced dropping of charges.
• Officer’s one-day suspension considered lenient.

Final Thoughts

• Importance of video footage in exposing police misconduct.
• Officer’s aggressive behavior vs. Cadon’s calm demeanor.
• Continuous need for public awareness and accountability in policing practices.