Discussion on Preferential Policies and Intellectual Elites

Key Points from the Discussion

Examination of Preferential Policies

• Opposition to Policy Changes: Any reevaluation of preferential policies will face strong opposition.
  • Charges of racism against opponents.
  • Labels of traitor for insiders who publicly disagree.

Personal Experience and General Observations

• Public Backlash: Example of Randall Kennedy being denounced for his views on preferential policies.
• Economic and Social Stakes: Many assumptions behind these policies must remain unchallenged to maintain the status quo for certain groups.
• Support from the Masses: Personal anecdote of being warmly received by ordinary individuals, indicating that opposition is not representative of the wider community.

Intellectuals vs. General Population

• Distinction: The vocal opposition usually comes from a small minority within the intellectual community, not the general black population.
• Vested Interest: Intellectual elites benefit from these programs and resist change to protect their interests.

Global Phenomenon

• Elites and Preferential Programs: Worldwide, elites benefit from preferential policies more than the masses.
• Example of Civil Rights Act: Predicted negative impact on working-class blacks due to reduced hiring incentives for entry-level jobs.

Evolution of Movements and Self-Interest

• Initial Idealism: Movements often start with genuine intentions (e.g., Martin Luther King, Malcolm X).
• Shift to Self-Interest: Over time, movements are co-opted by individuals with self-serving motivations (e.g., regulatory agencies, religious movements).

Quote Discussion

• Thomas Sowell's Quote: Reflects on the consequences of