Sonic The Hedgehog Movie Review and Critique Notes

Opening Remarks

• The reviewer makes a comparison between ring-shaped foods like Cheerios and SpaghettiOs.
• There is a comedic critique on Sega's long logo introduction.
• The narrative questions the success of a video game movie achieving both box office and critical acclaim.

Character and Plot Issues

• Chris, the character choice, is put into question regarding suitability.
• Alien hedgehogs' readiness compared to human waking habits is humorously critiqued.
• Issues with character eye design are noted.
• The sibling rivalry between characters is discussed, emphasizing the exaggerated nature due to their powers.

Plot Inconsistencies and Contrivances

• Tom’s reaction to Sonic's cave is called out as inconsistent with previous knowledge from the first movie.
• A forced heart-to-heart conversation is noted as having thin contextual background.
• Inconsistencies with physical objects, like missed blades not affecting outcomes, are highlighted.

Humor and Storytelling Mechanics

• The movie’s humor is critiqued, mentioning forced and cliché jokes.
• Overuse of flashbacks is critiqued as a storytelling mechanic.
• Misleading setup for dramatic reveals is noted as ineffective or overused.

Critique of Character Design and Story Elements

• Shadow's character introduction and backstory are criticized for lack of depth.
• The way super energy is handled is lightly critiqued.
• The movie's villain, Walter, has a backstory with inconsistencies.

Thematic and Logical Inconsistencies

• Trust issues are questioned in Sonic's character arc.
• Sonic’s use of technology and logical inconsistencies in planning are highlighted.
• Execution of dramatic scenes, involving outer space and physics, are critiqued.

Entertainment and Drawbacks

• Jim Carrey's performance as Robotnik is praised for entertainment but critiqued for overshadowing the plot.
• General critique of the movie's ability to balance its various narrative elements.
• The ending is critiqued for a lack of clarity on who has the advantage in the final race.

Conclusion and Future Implications

• The setup for future movies, involving characters like Metal Sonic, is noted.
• Speculation on plot developments and character arcs is made, leaving questions unanswered.
• The reviewer humorously signs off with culturally referential jokes and callbacks.