🎙️

Canada's Youngest Serial Killer Discussed

May 21, 2025

Dark Poutine Podcast - Episode Highlights

Introduction

  • Hosts: Mike Brown and Scott Hemway
  • Guest: Christy Lee from Canadian True Crime Podcast
  • Note: Scott is no longer with the show after episode 149
  • Content Warning: Mature themes, harsh language, and graphic descriptions of violent crimes

Episode Focus: Canada's Youngest Serial Killer

  • Main Subject: Peter Woodcock, a 17-year-old serial killer
  • Crimes: Murdered three children between 1956-1957, committed a fourth murder in 1991
  • Discussion: Nature vs. Nurture in the creation of a murderer

Peter Woodcock's Background

  • Born: March 5, 1939, in Peterboro, Ontario
  • Family: Born out of wedlock, mother unable to care for him
  • Early Life: Frequent foster homes, diagnosed with behavioral issues
  • Characteristics: Reactive attachment disorder (RAD), socially rejected, exhibited bizarre behaviors

Crimes and Escalation

  • Murder of Wayne Mallette: September 16, 1956
    • Details: Choked, bitten, bruised, and left in a secluded area
  • Murder of Gary Morris: Lower-class Toronto neighborhood
    • Details: Brutal beating, bite marks, and a ruptured liver
  • Murder of Carol Voice: January 19, 1957
    • Details: Choked, sexually assaulted, and mutilated

Investigation and Arrest

  • Initial Confusion: Wrongful conviction of Ronald Motte
  • Police Oversight: Failed to connect murders initially
  • Peter Woodcock's Arrest: Confessed to crimes, described violent fantasies

Trial and Incarceration

  • Verdict: Not guilty by reason of insanity
  • Incarceration: Spent 34 years in mental hospitals
  • Behavior in Prison: Model inmate, manipulated others

Release and Final Crime

  • Name Change: Became David Michael Krueger
  • Day Pass Murder: Killed Dennis Kerr on his first day out in 34 years
  • Return to Prison: Died of natural causes in 2010

Reflections and Ethical Implications

  • Discussion: Challenges in the justice system and mental health treatment
  • Public Reaction: Outrage over CPP payments to criminals

Podcast Highlights

  • Listener Engagement: Encouragement from listeners and other podcasters
  • Upcoming Topics: Less heavy topics planned, including LSD research in Canada
  • Host Reflections: Personal connection to adoption and RAD